Ratings & Reactions: Newcastle v Villa

[limpid]

Your ratings and reactions please. Keep it respectful even if you know everyone else is wrong.

A mod will add the players to the MoTM poll later.

[Nigel]

Emery had better be a miracle worker 

[Ingram85]

[Talldarkandransome]

It's not finished yet but I'm not voting for anything.

We should all just draw a line under this and move on to the Emery era

[Vive_La_Villa]

Why are our player so weak and unfit?

[Rodders]

Against that club? Particularly grim  but new era approaching, hopefully by the time of the re match we'll be in a much better place. The sound of the fans shameless cheering is so **** grim though. Hope they all choke on their dinner. Moral cowards

[theboyangel]

1 minute ago, Vive_La_Villa said:

Why are our player so weak and unfit?

Terrible training for the last 12 months

[rodders0223]

Time to start dismantling this team.

Bunch of good time players. Enough is enough.

[jacketspuds]

Still 15th but this team needs a top class player in defence, midfield and attack.

I also hate how smug Callum Wilson is.

[Wainy316]

Massive aids

[Davkaus]

I don't know how you go from that first half to that second half. We went in unlucky to be behind and had a couple of decent chances. That second half was the same old shit though, just a complete mental collapse. There's a lot of weakness in this squad.

[bose]

Mentally weak. We were fine in the first half. They get the penalty and we just give up and don’t turn up for the second.

Pathetic.

[Farlz]

Completely and utterly battered. 

At least it wasn't 6, all we can take from that. 

[Herman22]

I said from the start the ref was going to give them everything and it worked out that way! Everything went their way today! 

Best of luck Unai! 

[rbcuk]

That was awful, the whole defence needs to be upgraded, Watkins is just shit, coutinho didn’t even look interested when he came on

[StefanAVFC]

Absolutely dreadful 

[danceoftheshamen]

Embarrased to be a Villa fan today, amateurish performance all round including Danks who should have changed it after 5 mins of the second half. 

Beundia was attrocious, the front players all looked back to their usual standard (League 1). 

Nobody played well in that apart from Martinez when he was on. Absolutely woeful. Made a very average team look much better than they are.

Someone wake me up when there is a bit of promise in this team, especially away from home where they are, for me, the worst away team in the division by a country mile.

Big shout to the officials too for every single big decision going the way of the human rights abusers.

[KentVillan]

Just constantly ruined us down our left side, obviously picked Ashley Young out as a defensive weakness.

They were very good but we looked poor. Watkins in particular did absolutely nothing.

Time for Emery.

[ozvillafan]

Not mentally there. Once Olsen came on and the penalty given, that was it.

[UpTheVilla26]

Voted Ings MOM cos the poor bastard had to spend 93mins with no hope of getting a sniff. 

Shocking 2nd half, VAR is a joke and I hope when they come to VP later in the season, Emery will have this lot sorted and we pump them.