villalad21 7,025 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 (edited) Mid table player at best. Just my opinion. I think he is highly overrated in here. That being said i still like him. Just don't think he should be a starter. Edited March 3 by villalad21 1 Link to post Share on other sites
AndyM3000 1,379 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 Fantastic when we don't have the ball, not good in games like this when we do have it. Link to post Share on other sites
villa89 3,337 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 Stop shooting from outside the box john, thanks. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
turvontour 918 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 I always think McGinn plays better than the reactions on here. Wonder whether its sentiment and I want him to be better. Again I thought he was one of our better players tonight, which wasnt difficult. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
Zhan_Zhuang 1,511 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 I laid off him as many thought he was great against Leeds and we won but I didn't. Tonight again very poor. For me he's a Championship or bottom-level PL player. Tonight against the team bottom of the league he still cannot influence the game, he is too slow, weak, gives the ball away and his passing is inconsistent. McGinn saw a lot of the ball late in the game and really struggled to play anything worthwhile. He's a limited player who IS holding us back. 2 Link to post Share on other sites
andym 1,652 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 Had McGoldrick run right past him into the box for the goal Either go with him or make sure the defence know you are passing him on He did neither 1 Link to post Share on other sites
gaffer85 95 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 1 minute ago, andym said: Had McGoldrick run right past him into the box for the goal Either go with him or make sure the defence know you are passing him on He did neither Mcginn was bad for the goal but all the blame goes to Elmo( unless your sure there is nobody behind you ) you have to play the ball not leave and hope nobody's there Link to post Share on other sites
lexicon 5,712 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 28 minutes ago, andym said: Had McGoldrick run right past him into the box for the goal Either go with him or make sure the defence know you are passing him on He did neither Yeah - he messed up for it. I do wonder whether he's the answer going forward. Link to post Share on other sites
WooJung 529 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 2 hours ago, villalad21 said: Mid table player at best. Just my opinion. I think he is highly overrated in here. That being said i still like him. Just don't think he should be a starter. He's great on his day, has streaks of great form, but then has even longer streaks of average/kinda poor-ish performances with occasional bright sparks, such as a great long pass. He's hardly ever terrible though and I like him overall. His crossing tonight was dreadful, but so was everybody else's. It's as if we were playing with a lighter ball than usual. Link to post Share on other sites
PaulC 4,268 Posted March 3 Report Share Posted March 3 Not good but by far our best midfield player tonight. Link to post Share on other sites
Zatman 25,697 Posted March 4 Report Share Posted March 4 (edited) 3 hours ago, villalad21 said: Mid table player at best. Just my opinion. I think he is highly overrated in here. That being said i still like him. Just don't think he should be a starter. Phew thats good, are we not a midtable team Edited March 4 by Zatman Link to post Share on other sites
Zatman 25,697 Posted March 4 Report Share Posted March 4 He was OK today BUT his miss was shocking Link to post Share on other sites
lexicon 5,712 Posted March 4 Report Share Posted March 4 31 minutes ago, PaulC said: Not good but by far our best midfield player tonight. Nah. He was OK. Thought Marv was better. Link to post Share on other sites
Sulberto21 2,661 Posted March 4 Report Share Posted March 4 3 hours ago, Zhan_Zhuang said: I laid off him as many thought he was great against Leeds and we won but I didn't. Tonight again very poor. For me he's a Championship or bottom-level PL player. Tonight against the team bottom of the league he still cannot influence the game, he is too slow, weak, gives the ball away and his passing is inconsistent. McGinn saw a lot of the ball late in the game and really struggled to play anything worthwhile. He's a limited player who IS holding us back. Agreed. Great guy and all that but how many of the top 10 would he be starting at? Link to post Share on other sites
VT Supporter Tom13 1,170 Posted March 4 VT Supporter Report Share Posted March 4 He wasn't bad but I'm growing tired of his hit and hope shots from range and his obsession with playing a clipped ball over the top. Link to post Share on other sites
VT Supporter icouldtelltheworld 408 Posted March 4 VT Supporter Report Share Posted March 4 10 hours ago, turvontour said: I always think McGinn plays better than the reactions on here. Wonder whether its sentiment and I want him to be better. Again I thought he was one of our better players tonight, which wasnt difficult. Not at his best last night but was comfortably our best midfielder IMO. Not sure if it's because he's set such high standards previously, but he does seem to be judged more harshly than others 1 Link to post Share on other sites
PaulC 4,268 Posted March 4 Report Share Posted March 4 5 hours ago, icouldtelltheworld said: Not at his best last night but was comfortably our best midfielder IMO. Not sure if it's because he's set such high standards previously, but he does seem to be judged more harshly than others I think thats it. For me hes the only one of the midfield trying to make things happen Link to post Share on other sites
Nigel 5,211 Posted March 4 Report Share Posted March 4 13 hours ago, lexicon said: Nah. He was OK. Thought Marv was better. He wasnt! Link to post Share on other sites
VT Supporter wilko154 3,816 Posted March 4 VT Supporter Report Share Posted March 4 He wasn't the worst player on the pitch, let down by the lack of creativity and the tactics during the game. Crazy that Saturday he was heralded as being a vital part of the engine that beat Leeds and last night people are calling him to be sold. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
PaulC 4,268 Posted March 4 Report Share Posted March 4 1 minute ago, wilko154 said: He wasn't the worst player on the pitch, let down by the lack of creativity and the tactics during the game. Crazy that Saturday he was heralded as being a vital part of the engine that beat Leeds and last night people are calling him to be sold. Wasnt any worse last night but we lost a game we should have won. Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts