Scott Hogan

[Demitri_C 11,362]

Surely needs his own thread now as being reported everywhere and on yellow bar on Sunday.  I would assume the 10m we are getting from Westwood and ayew deals are what is funding this deal?

[Eastie 4,716]

Seems palace and West Brom are both sniffing around too so far from a done deal yet - could be a topsy turvy day ahead - imagine Rhodes is plan b but I hope we get one of the other and don't get gazumped late on hogan and see Sheffield weds pounce for Rhodes. 

I will glad when it is 11pm. 

Edited January 31, 2017 by Eastie

[Demitri_C 11,362]

I personally don't think this is gonna happen to be honest as can see a premier league team coming in for him. I think we are going to end up with Rhodes if a striker is coming in.

 

[Eastie 4,716]

Just now, Demitri_C said:

I personally don't think this is gonna happen to be honest as can see a premier league team coming in for him. I think we are going to end up with Rhodes if a striker is coming in.

 

I'd be happy enough to see Rhodes come in - think he might complement kodija better .

[Zatman 21,165]

much better all-round player than Rhodes and crucially has the ability to step up if we get promoted in season or two unlike Rhodes

also he might learn from Jack about turning down Ireland

[Hoof hearted 1,083]

I actually feel quietly confident on this one, kudos has to go to Round and Bruce for selling the club so well to Hortonheresawho and Lunchberry.

I think the fact that they have all (Hogan included) played at Villa park this season and have seen first hand that we are a Championship team in league position only, our facilities are world class and it's a great place to earn a living, hopefully we left a mark on Hogan in that way too.

[Demitri_C 11,362]

I personally don't think Hogan done any more than kodjia to think he is good enough to play in the premier league right now. Needs to play at a bigger club then if he succeeds think about premier league. 

[AVFC44 278]

Reckon we're being used to get West Ham to come back in for him. Think Hogan will hold out for a Premier League move as well.

[Jareth 8,475]

Steve B looked confident yesterday, probably gave him a great facial. 

[Ponky 3,188]

I think the club likes to be pretty confident the player will say yes before things get too advanced.

[nnock1984 251]

Not seen enough of this guy to see if he;s worth the figures muted.  Why is he rated more highly on here given Rhodes phenomenal scoring record?

[Wainy316 8,225]

Why would a team sell their best player to the team they are playing on that day?  I know he wouldn't be able to play against them but surely they'd want him to play for them?

[villa89 2,906]

16 minutes ago, AVFC44 said:

Reckon we're being used to get West Ham to come back in for him. Think Hogan will hold out for a Premier League move as well.

Once a bid was accpeted for Snodgrass from Burley West Ham came in and matched it. I expect the same to happen here.

[NIVillan 544]

Dean Smith the Brentford Manager would also sell Villa to him over the baggies

[TRO 13,691]

8 minutes ago, nnock1984 said:

Not seen enough of this guy to see if he;s worth the figures muted.  Why is he rated more highly on here given Rhodes phenomenal scoring record?

Not sure, but suspect, he makes more of his own goals, Rhodes, I think is more reliant on service.

[Jareth 8,475]

8 minutes ago, Wainy316 said:

Why would a team sell their best player to the team they are playing on that day?  I know he wouldn't be able to play against them but surely they'd want him to play for them?

I saw with bree and hourihane that the sum of 5 mill to smaller clubs is a huge deal, whereas to us we've just weeed away 10 mill on mclamemack. Not a fair playing field really.

[Villarocker 3,715]

Not too sure about this deal. I don't know much about the lad so it's difficult to comment on him but from what I have read I am confused.

Some say that Hogan is more mobile than Rhodes but then Rhodes has proven his ability to score at this level time and time again - scoring 91 goals in his last 187 Championship appearances, whereas Hogan has had one season of scoring prolifically at this level to his name. Also, with our new midfielders taking pot shots at goal we will need someone in and around the box to pick up the pieces and that's where Rhodes might just be, in the right place at the right time.

There's only 2 years difference in age and for the money being mentioned I am not sure that we should spend it on someone who has had one really good season at this level when we could get a player for less that has had four or five really good seasons at this level.

I suppose we simply have to trust that the management team make the right decision.

[Tomaszk 4,339]

He's a real all-rounder as a forward. More of a brain than Kodj.

[avfcDJ 10,612]

A lot of respected reporters seem to think it could happen.

 

I'm not believing it yet.

[PieFacE 9,095]

Where's my OYC?