Jump to content

Irreverentad's Relationship Advice Thread


irreverentad

Recommended Posts

18 hours ago, Ingram85 said:

Too nice? :huh:

Some Women really are glutton for punishment.

I agree mate. There is a woman at work who always goes for the type of bloke who gives her a kicking. Now, domestic violence is appalling and inexcusable but a part of me thinks that if she stopped going for, and I quote in her words, "bad boys", then she wouldn't come into work with black eyes and broken ribs. Oh yeah, she did date a nice guy once but dumped him as he was not exciting enough.

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, Xela said:

I agree mate. There is a woman at work who always goes for the type of bloke who gives her a kicking. Now, domestic violence is appalling and inexcusable but a part of me thinks that if she stopped going for, and I quote in her words, "bad boys", then she wouldn't come into work with black eyes and broken ribs. Oh yeah, she did date a nice guy once but dumped him as he was not exciting enough.

 

Ah the old I complain I get treated like crap but really I'd rather have this than find a nice guy as they bore me

No sympathy from me if you keep going back

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Come on people. We're talking about victims of domestic abuse here FFS. It is of course possible - indeed, it's common! - to love someone for whatever reason despite the abuse and for the victim to rationalise their mistreatment or blame themselves, refusing to see the evil in the person they love and being incapable of self-identifying as victims. 

It certainly does not mean that you should have 'no sympathy' for their situation. Honestly just read back what you're writing, it's on the verge of being morally repugnant. 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, HanoiVillan said:

Come on people. We're talking about victims of domestic abuse here FFS. It is of course possible - indeed, it's common! - to love someone for whatever reason despite the abuse and for the victim to rationalise their mistreatment or blame themselves, refusing to see the evil in the person they love and being incapable of self-identifying as victims. 

It certainly does not mean that you should have 'no sympathy' for their situation. Honestly just read back what you're writing, it's on the verge of being morally repugnant. 

Who said they should blame themselves? Please quote the person who actually said that?

People have merely said why go for the bad boys in the first place? You made the choice so if your not willing to make the decision to leave them then you live with the consequences.

If your afraid to leave the person because you are scared of being beat up or abused thats a completely different situation. I have seen no evidence that anyone here has said that. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, Demitri_C said:

Who said they should blame themselves? Please quote the person who actually said that?

People have merely said why go for the bad boys in the first place? You made the choice so if your not willing to make the decision to leave them then you live with the consequences.

If your afraid to leave the person because you are scared of being beat up or abused thats a completely different situation. I have seen no evidence that anyone here has said that. 

I didn't say you had said they should blame themselves? So I don't know what point you're getting hot under the collar about. 

I pointed out that victims sometimes do blame themselves for their own mistreatment, and offered that as an example of how victims may rationalise their abuse (and why it may seem to you, or anybody else looking in to a relationship, that the victim 'doesn't want to leave'). You talk about 'making the decision to leave' as if this is trivially easy - of course it may not be, for all sorts of reasons, both emotional and financial. 

And no, you cannot say 'you live with the consequences' - that is justifying abuse. Nobody should live with domestic abuse, regardless of your ill-informed speculation about whether they started a relationship because they like 'bad boys', which, just to be clear, you cannot possibly know. 

This is a serious topic, and you're treating it exceedingly trivially. Just stop. 

13 hours ago, Xela said:

I agree mate. There is a woman at work who always goes for the type of bloke who gives her a kicking. Now, domestic violence is appalling and inexcusable but a part of me thinks that if she stopped going for, and I quote in her words, "bad boys", then she wouldn't come into work with black eyes and broken ribs. Oh yeah, she did date a nice guy once but dumped him as he was not exciting enough.

 

While we're on the subject, I'm concerned about this as well. The way this post is written seems to suggest, without making it quite clear, that you are aware that a colleague of yours is a victim of domestic violence, seemingly rising to the level of 'broken ribs' (:excl::excl::excl:)? 

I must stress that I'm not a lawyer, but I strongly suspect this person is a victim of crime and what has happened to her is assault or grievous bodily harm. If you actually know this is the case, or have a very strong suspicion, then you may have a legal, as well as moral, obligation to report what you know. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, HanoiVillan said:

I didn't say you had said they should blame themselves? So I don't know what point you're getting hot under the collar about. 

I pointed out that victims sometimes do blame themselves for their own mistreatment, and offered that as an example of how victims may rationalise their abuse (and why it may seem to you, or anybody else looking in to a relationship, that the victim 'doesn't want to leave'). You talk about 'making the decision to leave' as if this is trivially easy - of course it may not be, for all sorts of reasons, both emotional and financial. 

And no, you cannot say 'you live with the consequences' - that is justifying abuse. Nobody should live with domestic abuse, regardless of your ill-informed speculation about whether they started a relationship because they like 'bad boys', which, just to be clear, you cannot possibly know. 

This is a serious topic, and you're treating it exceedingly trivially. Just stop. 

While we're on the subject, I'm concerned about this as well. The way this post is written seems to suggest, without making it quite clear, that you are aware that a colleague of yours is a victim of domestic violence, seemingly rising to the level of 'broken ribs' (:excl::excl::excl:)? 

I must stress that I'm not a lawyer, but I strongly suspect this person is a victim of crime and what has happened to her is assault or grievous bodily harm. If you actually know this is the case, or have a very strong suspicion, then you may have a legal, as well as moral, obligation to report what you know. 

Your the one who has turned this subject into some kind of silly debate. No one has inclined this kind of abuse is acceptable and you "say why am I getting hot under the collar" but then you write I am justifying abuse? Your talking absolute nonsense. How would you feel if I accused you of saying You justify abuse???  Then you try your best to try cause trouble with Xela as well. If you read Xela post he clearly states he finds it appauling and inexcusable and in addition states that the women in question herself that the woman says the nice guy was not "exciting enough"  Stop trying to cause trouble, and trying to ruin a good thread. 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, HanoiVillan said:

While we're on the subject, I'm concerned about this as well. The way this post is written seems to suggest, without making it quite clear, that you are aware that a colleague of yours is a victim of domestic violence, seemingly rising to the level of 'broken ribs' (:excl::excl::excl:)? 

I must stress that I'm not a lawyer, but I strongly suspect this person is a victim of crime and what has happened to her is assault or grievous bodily harm. If you actually know this is the case, or have a very strong suspicion, then you may have a legal, as well as moral, obligation to report what you know. 

The police were involved in that incident and it went to court, but the point i was trying to (badly) make is that she's been with guys before that one and after and suffered abuse with a lot of them, which is obviously horrific, but makes me think to myself that she needs to review the type of guy she finds 'exciting'. That's not me laying any blame on her, it just seems a very unfortunate coincidence. 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My mum was always attracted to bad boys and there was a few times when she had black eyes. The one bloke even broke bones the once. My grandad now and again hit my gran in the early years and if the villa got beat my gran used to have to keep out of his way once he came back from the game and the kids would have to hide. I used to knock my missus about in the early days of our relationship if I was drunk and we argued. Not proud of it but I came to my senses and stopped it. Tbf though she's attacked me a few times so it works both ways.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, Demitri_C said:

It does but realising its wrong and stopping it should be credited as well

I thought it was acceptable or should I say I thought it was acceptable for me to do it. I quickly realised it wasn't and I've not laid a finger on her For over 6 years and never will again. not proud of it but in the same breath I don't mind people judging me over it because it's only an Internet forum.

Edited by Rugeley Villa
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...
Â