Jump to content

The Best 'Best Ofs'


Xann

Recommended Posts

  • 10 years later...

Ok then. 

Do you prefer best of albums that go song by song in chronological order, or do you prefer a bit of variation in the running order?

Personally, I prefer it when it’s mixed up through the back catalogue. To briefly refer back to Pink Floyd as an example, their Echoes best of they released 20 years ago mixed up the various phases of their career.

I enjoyed the results hugely. Firstly, it irritated Roger having the stuff he played on mixed in with the stuff they did after he left - so that’s a positive. Secondly, a lot of their stuff typically segued from one song into another on the original recordings so to hear them mix the transition from Wish You Were Here to Jugband Blues to High Hopes kinda gives the songs a different flavour to the original album versions. Going from 1975, back to 1968 (or whenever the hell Syd thought he was back then) forward to 1994 is at least a bit more interesting to my ears than going in order.

Edited by Mark Albrighton
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 15/05/2013 at 20:54, saturdaygig said:

I've always rather disliked Greatest Hits type albums. Always feels rather like milking it.

I know in the case of oasis it was to fulfill a record deal commitment, that's why they've got 2

Stop the clocks is the better one though, more on it and better presented

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was just thinking whilst reading this (and the James Bond themes thread) that I don’t really listen to best ofs much.

Next album on… Memento Mori - a career spanning best of Barry Adamson, it even breaks my rule of no new singles :crylaugh: 

It also doesn’t contain any of his Visage tracks (they really wouldn’t fit)

It's great! (And looking at it, it’s one of those HMV haven’t got a clue about pricing albums. £16.99 for a double about 4 years ago
 

Which got me thinking about other best ofs and continuing the bass player theme… I Could've Been A Contender.At the time of release it was a career spanning best of Jah Wobble (it includes PIL tracks), his career has clearly gone on from the point of this Triple CD album, so it’s an early and mid period best of now but here’s the thing, the label that put it out was Trojan. Trojan, a label that specialises in Jamaican music puts out an album by a white bloke from London, it’s also a label he's never been on, so they had to licence every single track, which I guess frees them up to really choose the best tracks. I can’t think of another white artist that was ever released by Trojan, a complete oddity. An even bigger bargain bucket album bought for less than fiver in Sainsbury’s of all places

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Beach Boys / Ten Years of Harmony 1970-1980.

My favourite period by the band, included  two (at the time) unreleased tracks from the vaults and one that was only released on a movie compilation lp.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, theboyangel said:

Richard Hawley has just released Now Then: The Very Best of Richard Hawley. 

Great musician and probably deserves more acclaim.

See that's one I might get because I have only one Hawley album and I could do with more

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...
Â