I know where you're coming from, and the reasons behind your faith in Lambert. But I do think such optimism needs to be tempered by the fact that we spent the majority of last season thoroughly soiling ourselves at the specter of relegation. He hasn't done anything to justify such praise just yet, though he is certainly steering us in the right direction.
A necessary evil
Yes it was, and it paid off. But only just.
Lambert has still to elevate us above the levels attained by the much maligned messrs Houllier & messrs Mcleish. There are signs of a great future, but they need to be realised before we go overboard with the praise.
It is precisely because Lambert judged the scale of change to perfection and managed to change as much as he did while maintaining our league status that makes him such a good manager (in the literal sense) and judge. Yes it could have gone wrong, but ultimately it didn't, which means he was right; he was vindicated. We won't need to make that amount of change again un der him and he has made about 3 seasons worth of change in 1 season.
I see what you're saying BOF, but I do disagree to some extent. We can sit back and praise Lambert retrospectively because he just about got it right last season. But what if Gabby hadn't got that winner at Norwich and Wigan didn't inexplicably capitulate against Swansea? There was a big element of luck in our survival, and in my opinion we sailed a bit too close to the wind. I am fully behind his management, as I was all the way through last season, but our plight could have been very different and I'm not willing to sing his praises too much just yet.
You could equally say we had bad luck; late goals against us at Swansea, Baggies, Everton, etc. Dodgy decisions against us, such as that farcical penalty against the Saints. In the end doesn’t luck even it self up?