Do you not think for one second amongst the countless frustrating periods of poor form, 70 + goals all from open play in the premier league, countless derby winners and memorable performances, winners at places like Old Trafford and Anfield down the years in rare away wins there and the feeling yes he is one of us means people will feel a little more emotional attached to him than 90% of our squad given most players come and go.
Just looking at the countless forwards we've had in the last 10 years, some of these I've even forgot played for us, Harewood, Sutton, Baros, Allback, Heskey etc, these are players you forget about once they go as they were effectively passing through the club.
Even long after he's retired I'll still fondly remember some of the moments Gabby produced for this club so yes I'm not defending his frequent bouts of poor form but that's why he gets a bit more leeway from the fanbase on occasions.