Sorry, but the hiring of mcleish doesn't provide much evidence to back the optimistic view that lerner will get us challenging again.
Surely that depends how highly one rates Mcleish?
I rate him relatively highly, although given the groundswell of opinion against him, I think he's got his work cut-out to turn both the team, and importantly the fans, around.
I really don't understand why you rate him so higly Jon. His Premier League record is dismal, and there is no way that we should be bottom currently of the "also rans" league ie the all the teams other than the top and bottom 5. His style of football is awful, his results have been almost as bad, and his purchases not a lot better. I wish I could see something that inspires confidence in him, but there really is nothing. He isn't a good coach, the players don't seem to respect him and the vast majority of the fans didn't and don't want him. Other than ridiculous examples, I struggle to think of a worse manager Lerner could have picked. Most of us predicted poor, dull football leading to a possible relegation battle, and that's exactly what we've got.
I can see why lerner picked him, which I imagine is for two reasons. 1) He was desperate to get away from Blues, so would have taken any old job, and 2) it's a human shield for Lerner to hide behind.
some reasons why Lerner likes him (genuine)
1. he is prepared to work with what hes got and buys into the vision of lowering the wage bill.
2. He is prepared to work with the sell to buy policy put in place by the owner.
3. He is prepared to give our emerging youth players a chance
4. You wont see him slating the running of the club in the papers or bringing any bad press the clubs way for off the field activities.
5. RL believes in him, he must do else he wouldnt have employed one of the most hated managers in villas history.