Aye, they took on a legendary status for me when about six years ago one of them called up a phone-in show as a regular caller about something else and it somehow came up that he used to be in a band.
Various players and teams around the world for a number of reasons, but in the spirit of the answers so far:
Axel Tuanzebe
Albert Adomah
Tammy Abraham
Glenn Whelan
Mile Jedinak
I'll never forget the team that competed in the play-offs last season. I'm too young to remember a title win but Wembley in May was a high point like I never thought I'd experience. The club could have given them all contracts for life and I'd have been fine with it.