Thats about right, i'm looking to book with Chiltern too, £39.00 for two adults, return, no railcard though, just standard price.
Why do they all say 'Ticket only valid on services via High Wycombe'?
Because the faster trains from New st don't go through Wycombe whereas the chiltern do. Price restrictions.
Thanks mate, so you can only buy that ticket if you're departing from Moor Street/Snow Hill?
When you book online you have to specify a time to leave Moor Street and leave Wembley Stadium. Departure from Moor Street isn't a problem, but getting back, can't you have an open ended ticket? The stations going to be rammed after the game!
Can you get any trains from New Street to Wembley Stadium do you know?
Sorry, I'm asking you questions as if you work in the ticket office, open to anyone thats booked a train with Chiltern I suppose