Jump to content

Squad assessment


Recommended Posts

by JimCohen

So with pre-season well under way, with 3 new boys in and the squad for the U.S.A. announced; I thought I would cast an eye over our current team, assessing the strengths and weaknesses and looking to where Mr. Lambert may well be looking to strengthen.

Squad for United States Tour


Given, Guzan, Marshall, Siegrist (on Olympic duty)

I would say this is pretty strong and about as good as a club at our current level can expect. Yes Given had a poor Euros, but I think all true football fans know that he is a top class keeper who still has at least 3 seasons of Premier League football in him. He seems hungry to play and prove he is still one of the best and I think he could be a true Villa great of the modern era. Helping us get back to where we deserve to be. Remember how bad our back 4 was last season. To be fair to Given he didn’t look bad for us (apart from a few crosses he flapped at!). The back-ups are more than capable of stepping up and I think the re-signing of Guzan is very astute. To allow his development by us to go wasted at his age would be unforgivable considering the current climate and his performances during the winter months when Given was injured make me more than happy to have him as our number 2. In young Benji I would say we have a great prospect on our hands from what I have seen of the reserves and I look forward to seeing how he fairs at the Olympics. Marshall is there to play when everyone else is away, nothing more is needed than that.

Right Back

Lichaj, Lowton, Hutton (left home)

With Hutton left at home, it seems his cards are marked despite a solid first half on Saturday. I think most Villa fans would be delighted to see him go after what was a fairly poor season last year. Lichaj has shown a marked improvement since that Man City game when he was massively exposed and I look forward to seeing him play more next season. His attitude and versatility are a massive asset and I think he will be a solid squad member for years to come. I don’t think he is good enough for a starting spot at RB though, so a lot rests on what else we bring in (I am hearing a lot of rumours around Simpson) and how Lowton develops. I have not seen Lowton play much, but my Blades mates say he is a great player and they think he is good enough for the Premier League. He looked solid enough against Burton playing at centre half and again his versatility will be a massive asset, but I would like to see him make a real grab at the starting RB slot and hope to see him play there for the rest of pre-season. An exciting prospect. It could go either way at this stage, but if he steps up I would suggest we don’t need any more players at this area with Herd being a more than capable back-up to these two.

Centre Back

Dunne, Collins, Clark, Baker

An area that needs strengthening and with the talk around Vlaar mounting, I would suggest he could be a much needed addition to this part of our squad. I think Dunne and Collins are more than capable of playing in the Premier League, but neither will get us to the next level. Dunne gets too easily exposed by pace and Collins makes too many rash errors of judgement and his distribution goes from the sublime to the shocking with each pass. If I was the gaffer I would fine him every time he passed the ball more than 20 yards! However, if Vlaar comes, I would suggest his physical presence, aerial dominance and vast experience would work beautifully with the ever improving Clark. These two would be a great long term partnership and both are future captains. I am unsure if this will be our pair this year, one is still quite young and inexperienced and the other doesn’t even play for us (yet) but Dunne and Collins will still have a large part to play in our squad if they both remain at the Villa. I just don’t like them both playing too much together for too much longer. Baker looks like a great prospect, although the games I have seen him play for the first team he seems a different player to when he is in the reserves. He seems to panic and react physically to nerves, but when he overcomes this; and I am sure that he will; I think he could prove to be a very good Premier League player for us. I just hope we keep him long enough to get him to this level and he doesn’t become another Cahill.

Left Back

Warnock, Stevens

I would suggest that this area more than right backs needs strengthening. I think Warnock was worse than Hutton over the last season. He is rash in the tackle and is exposed positionally a great deal. His attacking threat is poor at best and I think his attitude is (allegedly) not one Lambert would enjoy working with (from what I have read). Stevens looked very good against Burton and I have read many good things about him but not seen him play that much myself. A good prospect for sure, but definitely not ready for a starting place. A new left back would be great, although not essential and perhaps Lichaj could come in here if Lowton was to start RB. A lot depends on Warnock and if he is still a player for us after the transfer window closes.

Right Wing

Carruthers, Albrighton (currently injured)

Two great prospects, but are either good enough to start? Albrighton flew onto the scene and has shown glimpses of brilliance. He works very hard for the team and seems to have an eye for goal, but his crossing and general distribution is not up to scratch and I fear he may never develop into the player we thought he could. Carruthers looks just as good a prospect as Albrighton did and although massively untested at this stage I think he will get a fair bit of game time in the States. I doubt, however, that he will be starting at Upton Park come opening weekend as I sense we may well play more of a 4-3-3 like we did in the second half of the Burton game. Either way, whatever formation we play, he is not ready to start consistently. A great impact sub and he may well get a run of 3 to 4 games at some point in the season, but he is not a current starter. With many of our central players being able to play here and of course the left wingers being able to switch, I would suggest this is not a priority, but on the other hand, I would also suggest this is currently our weakest area of the squad and as such it should be the next thing to address if we are going to play 4-4-2.

Centre Midfield

El Ahmadi, Bannan, Herd, Delph, Gardner, Johnson, Makoun (visa issues), Petrov (long term illness)

I am in two minds here. We have great depth, that is for sure. We have great players as well. El Ahmadi could turn out to be the buy of the season for us and the younger players are all good prospects. But do any of you have two players from this list that you are happy to see in a starting midfield pair in a 4-4-2? If we were to play 4-3-3 I feel a lot more comfortable with the likes of Herd and Bannan getting a game, but it does feel a little lightweight and exposed with any pairing as a two. I would suggest that if our captain Petrov is not going to play for a considerable amount of time to come, this area needs addressing. However, I would hate to see the opportunities of Bannan, Herd and Gardner further limited by new signings. This is the issue. We have so many great prospects here, I think we need to loan out at least 1 (probably Gardner), sell at least 1 (probably Delph), put Johnson back into the reserves for one more season and say to the others (Herd and Bannan), you will have to fight it out for game time between yourselves and maybe one more signing.

Left Wing

Holman, N’Zogbia

Very happy with this area now. In short, Holman looks like he is going to be a very good buy for us and perhaps one of the few good things Big Eck did! He looked very good against Burton, full of running, defensively responsible and with an eye for goal. It’s early stages and apart from this game I have only seen him play around 3 times, but I do like the look of him. He works well in a 4-4-2 or 4-3-3 and his versatility I think will give him a lot more game time than many expect. Charley Boy needs to step up, but he has the ability to do just that. The stories I have heard about some of his absences last season are shocking, but with Lambert at the helm and with him pretty much wasting 1 precious year of his short career, I would hope that he gets his head down and starts working. A great talent and I hope he realises what a lucky man he is and shows us what he can do.

Attacking Midfield


With Bannan and Holman being able to play here I would suggest this is OK to have just one player in the “hole” but of course Ireland, like N’Zogbia, hasn’t quite settled into life at Villa as well as we had hoped. However, he has shown glimpses of brilliance and he does offer something no other player at the club does. I fear for his game time though because at Norwich, Wes Hoolahan (the closest player in terms of style at NCFC) was very much in and out of the team. I sense he is a “home” player. Someone to play the unexpected defense splitting pass when we have more possession and need to break down opposing defenses, but I hope he steps up to become a regular starter for the club, because an in form Ireland is a very good player. Like Bannan and Herd, in a 4-3-3 I feel a lot more comfortable with Ireland, so perhaps a lot depends on how we play.


Bent, Gabby, Weimann, Delfouneso

I would suggest that like our GK department, this is as good as a club like us, in our current position could do. Bent is a natural goalscorer and a top top player. He clearly works better with a more creative team behind him and to judge him on games when he has played with the other 10 players behind him, doing what they were being told to do, is harsh at best, but despite this and despite his injury, he still remained our top scorer last season. He will score goals. He will offer players around him hope that we are a big club. He will draw the international manager to Villa park and he will win us games. Gabby is a similar player in terms of confidence I would suggest. He plays a lot better when he is not thinking, but instinctively reacting. He doesn’t like to play the main striker, we have seen that many times, so we shouldn’t judge him on the games he played pretty much alone without Bent when he was asked to lead the line, work the channels, hold the ball up and score the goals. That is too much for a player like Gabby. But ask him to float behind the front man, work the channels and cut in and cross or shoot and you have a very dangerous player on your hands. The one we saw at the start of last season and for most of his Villa career. I think Gabby and Bent could be a great front pairing and work well in a 3 with either N’Zogbia or Holman. Weimann is a great prospect. He seems like a real poacher and a real hard worker. It just looks like he wants to succeed. I think he will become a real star for us and is a more than capable back-up or impact sub for this season. Mr. Delfouneso on the other hand, I would suggest, is on his last chance. He has all the natural talent to be a success but his attitude does not seem to be right for whatever reason. Maybe he doesn’t like having to play the channels. Maybe he is a confidence player who finds it hard being a bit part player. Whatever it is, time is running out and I would suggest that unless he steps up he will be shipped out. At which point we would need to replace him, but for now I would suggest we are OK. If we sign another striker in the near future he will go either on loan or to a Championship club for £1m or so. Until then he has to take every chance he gets.

So in summary, if Vlaar comes, I would suggest we need a new RM, LB and CM in that order, unless other players leave. However, having already brought in 3, is another 4 a little greedy despite the fact that Cuéllar and Heskey have gone?

I do think we have a good mix of youth and experience. A solid if unspectacular squad and if the new recruits bed in as we hope, the younger players develop as they could and the older pros play as they should, then we could find ourselves having a much better season than we expect.

Up the Villa!

This post has been promoted to an article

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That was a good read and I must concur with most of it. I think it shows how, with an astute Manager, we are well equipped to try different styles of play at different times. As PL is known for this it is another reason to feel exciteed and positive about the new season.

Probably the only point I would differ on is up front, Delfunso is not going to cut it and we can't be sure about Weimann. Although I think PL will get goals from elsewhere in the Team we need more than just Bent and a - hopefully rejuvenated - Gabby. Who ? Don't know, but not Owen !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with your dilemma around central midfield. I've had the same dilemma for a while now. To an extent even when Petrov was available, I couldn't see a cast-iron partner for him.

We do have numbers there but we don't have 2 obvious starters. So you end up in a situation where you've a collection of 'Jacks of all trades' and masters of none. We are also assuming El Ahmadi will answer all of our prayers. He may well do. He probably will do. But what if he doesn't? What if he's a Makoun/Berson/Djemba twins mark 2?

The other positions on the pitch are largely made up of known quantities even if we don't have numbers there. And the pitch-side positions (full back and wingers) are not as important as the central midfielders are. So I think it's vital that Lambert comes back from America with a very clear idea of what he'll be doing in the centre of the park. Whether that means another new addition or settling on a combination of what we've already got.

We can't go into the season with everything else sorted and a revolving door policy in the centre of the park. I'd also point out that I don't for a minute think PL will do that. I'm just saying it should be top of his 'to do' list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say looking at that we need to purchase a right back, a left back, two centre halves, two central midfielders,two wingers and a striker.

I would like to see the back of Hutton, Warnock, Collins, Makoun, Delph, Bannan, Allbrighton and Fonz

I still think that the squad is very poor and lacks quality and depth and is especially weak at full back and centre mid

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A really spot-on assessment. Just hope PL has a report along these lines sitting on his desk, downloaded on his iPad, stitched inside his jacket lining etc.

The defence needs most work imo. We really need to build a new regular CB partnership for the future and we won't make real progress until we have done that. But the biggest need is at RB and LB where we need a complete change.

I reckon one strong character with dependable tackling and passing coming into midfield would be a good enough foundation to allow the rest to flourish - we do have quite a lot of talent in there.

For me the two who really have to deliver much more this season are Gabby and Zoggy (sounds a bit like a Channel 4 kids' programme :)). Hope they are put on notice to that effect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I hope we don't try and play 4-4-2 next year but instead opt for a 4-2-3-1/4-5-1/4-3-3. Many moan that this is not attacking enough, especially at home, but I think it can be more attacking if the three are creative and they push on when in possession. I also think that the 4-4-2 is not very attacking if the two in CM can never win the ball.

For me, I would be happy with:

----------------- Given --------------

Lowton --- Vlaar --- Clark --- NEW

------------------ KEA ---------------

------------- Delph/Makoun --------

NZogbia --------- SI ---------- NEW

------------------ Bent --------------

I think KEA potentially sorts our DCM hole that we have had for years and, alongside him, any one of Delph, Makoun, Gardner or Bannan would get a chance to play as the playmaker which would suit them all much better than how they were being used by Muppet McLeish.

with a back up of:

-------------------- Guzan --------------------

Lichaj ------- NEW --- Baker ------ Stevens

-------------------- Herd ---------------------

------------ Delph/Makoun/Gardner --------

Albrighton --- Gardner/Holman --- Holman

------------------- Gabby --------------------

With Carruthers, Johnson, Weiman and the Fonz battling it out as well. You could put Bannan in there alongside a DCM, although I prefer Delph or Makoun and, with Gardner as back up as well, I would probably let Barry go if we could get in £3million + for him. This would be alongside last season's back 4!

So I have three gaps (I'm assuming Vlaar is here) at LB, CB (depending on how much we spend this might be a first choice in front of Clark - really wish we had kept Carlos) and a right winger. Not sure about the first two but I wouldn't mind Phillips from Blackpool as the winger.

I would be happy with this.

If we were going to splash out on a striker (and possibly send the Fonz out on loan/sell him) I would like to see a young talent like Rhodes or Wickham, who has struggled at Sunderland. I do think it is hard to keep 4 strikers happy when you play a sole striker though. Maybe a swap - Gab for Wickham + some cash - and this would give us a different option i.e. a big strong no. 9.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:thumb: Great assessment. For such a long article there's very little to disagree with. I rate Lichaj a bit higher than that, and for me Weimann is about on a par with Gabby in terms of who should get a start. I also have a bit more faith that PL will find some combination of our existing midfielders that works. That's about it.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fantastic Assesment and would agree with it on the whole.

Personally think we need rid of Hutton, Collins & Potentially Warnock.

Definitely need a new CB (Vlarr would be excellent) and possibly a new LB if Warnock leaves.

Midfield is a head scratcher. I honestly believe Makoun is a superb player (if given a chance) and could set up a fantastic pairing with KEA. Delph also has the ability to step up. If one of those was to be sold Id be in the market for a new CM. Potentially loan out Herd, Gardner or Johnson.

Wingers I think we are fine. I always will see Bannan as a winger (he's too lightweight in the middle). With that in mind that gives us Albirghton, Holman, N'Zogbia, Bannan and Curruthers.

Would like to see a target man up front with Benty/Gabby. Whether that Carroll we'll see.

In order we need desperately CB, LB, F, CM.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say looking at that we need to purchase a right back, a left back, two centre halves, two central midfielders,two wingers and a striker.

I would like to see the back of Hutton, Warnock, Collins, Makoun, Delph, Bannan, Allbrighton and Fonz

I still think that the squad is very poor and lacks quality and depth and is especially weak at full back and centre mid

I'd agree we are weak in several positions, but I don't see Randy funding this amount of new players without several being sold first.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say looking at that we need to purchase a right back, a left back, two centre halves, two central midfielders,two wingers and a striker.

I would like to see the back of Hutton, Warnock, Collins, Makoun, Delph, Bannan, Allbrighton and Fonz

I still think that the squad is very poor and lacks quality and depth and is especially weak at full back and centre mid

I'd agree we are weak in several positions, but I don't see Randy funding this amount of new players without several being sold first.

I wonder how easily we can shift some of the deadwood I mentioned. Could probably find takers for the younger ones like Delph, Bannan, Allbrighton and Fonz.

Makoun could probably have an exit route back to Europe but I think Hutton, Collins and Warnock may be tricky due their wages and lack of ability

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great article and agree with most of it :thumb:

I would see LW, as opposed to RW, being a position to fill (Charlie likes to play on the right). I also think that we should bite the bullet and sell The Fonz and buy in a new Striker. Carroll fits the mould as he offers something that Bent and Gabby don't, but he wouldn't play every game, so I don't think it'll be him.

These signings aren't greedy as I can see Hutton, Collins, Warnock, Makoun (unfortunately), Delph (loan) and The Fonz going.

Good read!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Well I wanted 4 more when we had 3 and we bought 5! Good work PL!

We got the lb we needed, the extra cm that we all wanted and the extra man up top as well as of course Vlaar. As well as more youth up top.

My only concern is that from all 8 of these players I have to honestly say I had heard of none of them before we were seriously linked with them!

8 players plucked from obscurity for the regular footy watcher makes for an excited but slight nervous fan

I hope they will all step up and if they do what youthful bargains they will all be but goodness, it's a bit of a long shot that they will all make it isn't it?

But in summery I am delighted and look forward to seeing them all don the mighty claret and blue

A fun window


Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Create New...