Very defeatist. I completely appreciate it can feel like we'll get back in to our old cycle of being a selling club, but I think the difference is when the other players left (Yorke, Barry, Milner, Young etc) they were very good players leaving a decent to slowly middling team. This Jack situation is very unique, he's a truly world class player in a decent side. I don't for a second want him gone, but the possibility is still there to reinvest in 2 or three positions and make the overall team a much stronger outfit. Let's not forget we've struggled every time Jack was out injured, and that needs addressing even if he stays. Creating a stronger unit could still give us a boost and push us on a level, rather than having to resort to selling our best players every summer.
Utilise the money like Liverpool did with Coutinho and we could boost the whole club.
That said, I'd much rather we not face that possibility, and I hope common sense prevails and he stays to become a bonafide legend at the club, and takes us with him to where he wants to be.