Jump to content

Value of players?


Dodgyknees
 Share

Recommended Posts

I've just been sat writing down on some paper the players I will have for FM14 (I am at work, but the office is a lonely one...).

 

I was listing how much I could make from player sales, when I started to wonder how much our team is worth in real life? I think we are already worth 5x (in total) what we were last year and players are still improving which adds to value.

 

(I am putting estimated costs, I cannot remember all).

 

Bought for / now worth

 

Guzan: £0m / £15m (is this cheating, do I put previous fee?)

 

Lowton: £1.5m / £4m

 

Bacuna: £1.5m / £3m

 

Bennett: £1.5m / £2m

 

Luna: £1.5m / £3m

 

Vlaar: £3.5m / £3.5m

 

Clark: £0m / £5m

 

Baker: £0m / £4m

 

Okore: £4m / £4m

 

Albrighton: £0m / £1m

 

Tonev: £2m / £2m

 

Delph: £6m / £8m

 

Sylla: £0.5m / £2m

 

El Ahmadi: £2m / £3m

 

Westwood: £1m / £5m

 

Agbonlahor: £0m / £8m

 

Weimann: £0m / £5m

 

Kozak: £4m / £4m

 

Helenius: £1m / £1m

 

Benteke: £5m / £40m

 

Plus we have a few others such as Herd and Steer who are now worth more.

 

Is this proof we are on the way up? Most players have seen a rise on their values (in my opinion) which has to be a good sign? Am I close to possible values or have I under/over-rated some?

Edited by dodgyknees
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think you're a bit too optimistic at times. IMO:

Guzan: £7m 

Lowton: £2.5m

Bacuna: £2m

Bennett: £1m

Luna: £1.5m 

Vlaar: £3.5m 

Clark: £3m

Baker: £3m

Okore: £4m

Albrighton: £0.5m

Tonev:£2m

Delph:£10m

Sylla: £1m

El Ahmadi: £2m

Westwood: £3m

Agbonlahor: £6m

Weimann: £8m 

Kozak: £4m

Helenius: £1m

Benteke: £30m

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tonev: 50p

 

Hopefully his value will increase

 

 

Way optimistic with a few of those but I have noticed as fans we tend to over value our players. Second list looks about right.

 

I'm usually pessimistic, throw me some credit!

Edited by dodgyknees
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • VT Supporter

Maybe it would be even more credible, if even one player was worth less now than at the time of purchase?

 

My suggestion: Tonev 1 mill. He was better when we only watched YouTube clips and no-one could actually see him play.

Edited by AVTuco
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe it would be even more credible, if even one player was worth less now than at the time of purchase?

 

My suggestion: Tonev 1 mill. He was better when we only watched YouTube clips and no-one could actually see him play.

 

I think the Tonev value is fair to be honest.

 

I'd rate Ireland at £8m / £0m but he is no longer with us.

 

I guess I can put Given in, I forgot about him - £5m / £0m

 

Other than that our team's value is moving in the right direction. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • VT Supporter

 

Maybe it would be even more credible, if even one player was worth less now than at the time of purchase?

 

My suggestion: Tonev 1 mill. He was better when we only watched YouTube clips and no-one could actually see him play.

 

I think the Tonev value is fair to be honest.

 

I'd rate Ireland at £8m / £0m but he is no longer with us.

 

I guess I can put Given in, I forgot about him - £5m / £0m

 

Other than that our team's value is moving in the right direction. 

 

 

No doubt.

Edited by AVTuco
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe it would be even more credible, if even one player was worth less now than at the time of purchase?

My suggestion: Tonev 1 mill. He was better when we only watched YouTube clips and no-one could actually see him play.

I think the Tonev value is fair to be honest.

I'd rate Ireland at £8m / £0m but he is no longer with us.

I guess I can put Given in, I forgot about him - £5m / £0m

Other than that our team's value is moving in the right direction.

What about Bent? £24m to approx £2m :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • VT Supporter

 

 

Maybe it would be even more credible, if even one player was worth less now than at the time of purchase?

My suggestion: Tonev 1 mill. He was better when we only watched YouTube clips and no-one could actually see him play.

I think the Tonev value is fair to be honest.

I'd rate Ireland at £8m / £0m but he is no longer with us.

I guess I can put Given in, I forgot about him - £5m / £0m

Other than that our team's value is moving in the right direction.

What about Bent? £24m to approx £2m :P

 

Yep, he's still our player....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

 

Maybe it would be even more credible, if even one player was worth less now than at the time of purchase?

My suggestion: Tonev 1 mill. He was better when we only watched YouTube clips and no-one could actually see him play.

I think the Tonev value is fair to be honest.

I'd rate Ireland at £8m / £0m but he is no longer with us.

I guess I can put Given in, I forgot about him - £5m / £0m

Other than that our team's value is moving in the right direction.

What about Bent? £24m to approx £2m :P

 

Yep, he's still our player....

 

 

Fair point! 

 

Proves my point that we are a team who are on the way up - if we look at those signed under Lambert and those who play a majority of the games. Any player signed previously was on the way down.

Edited by dodgyknees
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guzan 7.5m

Steer 1m

Given 500k

Baker 3m

Vlaar 4m

Okore 5m

Clark 4m

Stevens 500k

Bennett 2.5m

Luna 2.5m

Hutton 2m

Lowton 4.5m

Westwood 4m

Herd 1.5m

Sylla 3.5m

Bacuna 2m

El Ahmadi 2.5m

Delph 4m

Gardner 1m

Allbrighton 750k

Nzogbia 5m

Tonev 2m

Agbonlahor 10m

Wiemann 8m

Helenius 2m

Benteke 25m

Bowery 750k

Kozak 6m

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...
Â