If you mean don't, then I agree with you.
Yeah sorry I meant don't.
From our current squad of players 4-4-2 MIGHT work with Chris Herd being one of the two in the middle, he's the only as far as I can see who can tackle and track back efficiently. Petrov however should be nowhere near the team if we were to play 4-4-2. Our full backs would need to be good offensively and defensively also which, well you know how it is...
------------------- Given ---------------------
---- Hutton -- Cuellar -- Dunne -- Warnock
-- N'Zogbia -- Gardner -- Herd -- Ireland --
-------------- Bent -- Agbonlahor ------------
If we were to play 4-4-2, that would be the best team we would be able to use in my opinion.
On paper the way the formation McLeish picks (the 4-2-3-1) should be the best way for our current set of players to play, he just sends them out with a defensive mentality which quite frankly doesn't even work.