haha like it dodgy knees well this "is" an aston villa fans forum and forums are used to discuss opinion SGC, your opinion may be that McEachran is better than GG, fair play to you, but in my opinion Mceachran had been VERY hyped up by the press as he came through as a 17year old, GG would have been in that position had he not had his injury which lets not forget set him back a good year or so! Gardner is more of a box to box midfielder and Mceachrans more of a deeper playmaker if FM and MOTD tells me anything.