Not for me. If others are being generous he was th ebest of a bad bunch, but he did little for me other than run into trouble and generally being in the wrong place. All the backside-out physical stuff did nothing today, I just don't see a player there at the moment, maybe a change on formation or personnel around him would improve him? I just don't know if he is one of those players who is great in the Championship but can't find his feet at PL level - there are plenty of them. I think he needs to be set free to get forward, he is very shackled at the moment.