I did say it was easily the best game of the past 6 years. But then it was followed by easily the worst game of the past 6 years in the next round which pretty much cancels it out.
He had a nice little run at the start of his tenure for sure (but his league form wasn't even that impressive, 5 wins from 13...or 7 losses from 13 depending on how you want to look at it), but was an utter car crash not soon after, and that's after being given the funds he needed to reshape the squad and pretend like he knew about French football. 9 losses out of 10, don't think even Garde got close to being that bad, he was easily in a class of his own.
Also can we take a moment to remember how he didn't even have his coaching badges before he became manager. Of Aston Villa Football Club. In the Premier League. The man was our Donald Trump.