Riiight so that is why MON has won 7 games in 11 at Sunderland in 2 and half months.
Whilst meahwhile McLeish has managed 6 wins in 23 games all season despite having a better squad and whole summer to sign his own players.
Not really read my post have you. But yeah pretty much the response I expected.
The point I am making is that MON has been made out to be messiah whilst at Villa. Yes he was successful for us. But I am suggesting that it was in a 'window' of great opportunity. Massive backing, with the Sky 4 starting to wobble, there was room for a new boy, it could and probably should of been Villa. I think he blew the one chance we had where others may of been a bit less 'this is the Martin O'Neil show' and more lets get Villa back into the English elite.
Not a dig at MON, just making a different point/argument to the one banged out so many times on here.
MON had faults and yes he did blow a great chance for the top 4 in the 2008-09 season.
But after that the squad was stripped apart by our board.
You said that McLeish would have done just as good job.
Based on what??
MON had pedigree as a Premiership manager from his time at Leicester before he joined us.
McLeish has only record of Premiership failure.
What on earth makes you think he would have done as well as MON?
Nevermind talking about hypotheticals the FACT is MON is currently doing a better job at Sunderland than McLeish is doing here.
7 wins in 11 games
compared to 6 wins in 23 games ! :oops: