I agree he is not one of the worst players ever to grace the shirt, but I wish people would stop banging on about his goals tally as if it is something wondrous. It is 70 goals over what, roughly 10 years. Lets be generous and say 10 goals per season on average....... from one of your main strikers, club captain, Villa fan - thats a pretty poor return.
Wonder how many McCormack would score over the same period, what about Carew, even the idiot Baros? I would wager that all of them would score more.
And there were only 2 (maybe 3) seasons were his tallies were good, and he looked decent. Decent, no more than that.
Over the last 5 years he has just taken the piss. For that he needs to go. He deserted us in our hour of need. Unforgivable.
He is not a good enough player now (and wasn't at his peak) to be forgiven for the things he has done. In addition, letting him back into the fold would send completely the wrong message to the rest of he squad about attitude and commitment. We are trying to shake off the malaise of the past -- Gabby is the very epitome of everything that was wrong.