So I am definitely in the out camp. Bruce for me is not adventurous enough for a club like Villa and is a lower end of the premier league slogger. There is a reason he has 4 promotions - he has ended up in the Championship A LOT, premier league clubs have not exactly fallen over themselves to hire him - that should say a lot. He also has two relegations from the prem lets not forget. He is good at getting the best out of a skillfully poor but hardworking team. He has never shown flair in his teams and has never managed at the top end of the prem. He also apparently stays awake all night worrying about losing. Not something that instills confidence is it!
He has not, over 40+ games consistently demonstrated a game plan, a playing style, a first choice team or a plan B. He has not shown an ability to change a game when it is going against us or even try until it is too late.
What I want to see from Bruce, if he is to stay, a period of 10+ wins where it looks like we deserved to win where we looked convincing and didn't only play for 1 half of the game. Not like the winning run last season where the wins were not convincing and there was a fair degree of luck, and you just felt that we could not sustain it - and we didn't. Norwich was a good start. 10 more performances like that and I will have been brought onside. I would even accept a couple of draws in some circumstances (i.e. not if we throw away a 3-0 lead and draw 3-3) .
Each win or decent performance that he gets (like Norwich) buys him until the next game in my eyes.