No it isn't. It's like saying a player has no left foot, or isn't good in the air.
A keeper's job is to stop goals from being scored, and part of that means good positioning, claiming crosses, organising his defence, etc. so that he doesn't have to do flashy saves.
Given was the best shot stopper in the league for a few seasons, yet none of the top 4 came in for him. There's a reason for that.
Yeah - Van Der Sar, Cech, Reina etc... were already in place at current clubs
And Man City refused to sell to Arsenal. I think. We know how Wenger has his restraints.
Given is a good goalkeeper. As long as he passes his medical and is injury free I would be very happy with that signing.