VillaTalk blog

  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Contributors to this blog

Player Match Ratings: 3 more points - There’s lovely!

Sign in to follow this  


Yesterday’s third successive home win extended Steve Bruce’s unbeaten run to seven games. It also lifted us into the top half of the table and put us within touching distance of a place in the top six.

Cardiff have not won at Villa Park since 1954 but they started strongly and reacted well to going a goal down after 24 minutes by drawing level 4 minutes later. Our visitors gave the sort of determined no-nonsense display that is expected from any team managed by Neil Warnock. It’s not pretty to watch but it is effective and it will be likely to be enough to keep our visitors up this season. On this occasion, another goal from Kodjia and a late penalty secured the points for us.  

We will see much more entertaining games at Villa Park this season but these are the sort of games that teams who go on to win promotion emerge from with the points. It is such a relief to see us winning games again at what is fast becoming fortress Villa Park again. It is also a bonus to see us score three goals when we have otherwise not played particularly well.  

My player ratings from a game that we scored three goals in for the first time since our opening home game of the season are:

Pierluigi Gollini – 6 – Got down well to hold a 46th minute header from Hoilett.     

Alan Hutton – 5 – Cardiff found it easier than it should have been to make some decent runs down his side in the first half and Alan needed to show a little more alertness when he was slow in trying to get back to cover the unmarked Lambert on the edge of the box for their equalizer.   

James Chester - 8 – MOTM – Did not put a foot wrong at the back.       

Nathan Baker – 6 – Looked solid prior to his half time substitution due to injury.

Jordan Amavi – 8 – Continues to look better with every game and claimed a big assist for our first goal. Hit a left footed shot from the edge of the box on 33 minutes that was blocked by a defender.

Albert Adomah – 7 – Scored our opener on 24 minutes. Amavi made a nice run before hitting a low cross to the far post where Albert took a touch before coolly slotting the ball past Amos.    

Ashley Westwood – 6 – Lost a challenge that he had started favourite to win in the build up to their equalizer but put in a decent enough shift other than that.

Mile Jedinak – 7 – Another very strong midfield performance. 

Jack Grealish – 7 – Earned us a late penalty when he was brought down inside the box by Morrison after Kodjia had played a nice ball for him to run onto. Our visitors had found Jack too tricky to handle when he had the ball at his feet and resorted to stopping him in the only reliable manner they could think of namely by bringing him down. They eventually paid the price for that tactic having Peltier sent off on 84 minutes and conceding the late penalty that clinched our win.     

Jordan Ayew – 4 – Very, very quiet yesterday. Lost the ball a little too often and did not seem to be looking too hard to impose himself upon the game

Jonathan Kodjia – 7 – Got on the end of a ball that Baker had played from well inside his own half on 11 minutes and made space for a shot that took a slight deflection off Peltier before flying just wide of the far post. Had a decent goal scoring opportunity on 85 minutes but hit the ball wide of the post. Scored our second on 39 minutes. Adomah was given a second opportunity to put a cross in and hit the bouncing ball to the far post where Jonathan climbed well above a statuesque defender to plant his header past the keeper.        


Tommy Elphick – 6 – Started the second half as Baker’s replacement and looked solid.        

Gabriel Agbonlahor – 6 - Replaced Ayew on 62 minutes. Grealish put him clear with a lovely ball on 79 minutes but Amos came out to block his shot and he then scuffed an attempted cross from the rebound. Booked shortly after coming on for his reaction to a decent penalty appeal that he had played a big part in being denied.      

Rudy Gestede – 6 - Replaced Adomah on 74 minutes. Sent Amos the wrong way and hit the ball into the left corner of the net from the spot in the 90th minute to extinguish any hopes our visitors may have entertained of claiming a stoppage time equalizer. I must admit that I was more than a little worried when he was the one that stepped up to take it though.

Up the Villa!

John Lewis

Sign in to follow this  


  • Posts

    • I think this thread is proving to people that there's not much better than Bruce available currently. 
    • RDL not convinced by at all but would happily give him another chance. McCormack and Gardner can go. We need more pace and energy, not more of a lack of it! Happily give Gil another chance as he's a player I like, but not convinced we will. Gollini hasn't even been playing has he? But I always thought he was a bit harshly criticised. I'm guessing Tshibola isn't gonna make it...will be sold now?
    • Conceded 5 in 2 games vs both Sevilla and Roma who arent top of table European teams His shot stopping not even that great, he made same mistake vs Roma but Kolarov shot hit bar
    • Bruce has failed, but it's a very fine line of failure. I'll say it again, but my worry is who do we replace him with. We ain't going to get no top manager to drop down a league, and anyone else is a gamble imo. Bruce would be the safer bet, because we know he does have it in him to get teams out of this league. With the money spent, and being the biggest club in the division comes along with that a lot of pressure. I'd be happy for him to go providing we have a good replacement. The reality is that I don't think there is a good replacement available. 
    • It definitely could be, but we wouldn’t be getting a player anywhere near as good as him as replacement. In the Championship, I think those kind of players make a massive difference - possibly not so much in the Prem. Would I rather have £30m or Jack Grealish? Probably the latter. 
    • Its easy to say promote a youngens and rely on them but I don't think they are anywhere near ready. Rhm came on against Bolton and looked as though he's never played before, Davis goalscoring record will not help us next season, ohare doesn't look ready just yet either. Sulliman failed in his loan because he is not there physically yet so he'd have no chance in this division.    We have some great young talent there's no denying that but throw them all in to early and there careers will be over before they've even started. 
    • I've always said Gil could be at least a good player at this level, would not at all be against bringing him back in but that said, he has said before that he has no interest at playing at this level so not sure I can see a way back for him, unless his mind has changed... McCormack is too old, expensive and limited for my mind, one of those who is a hindrance to how the team plays overall. Gollini was a car crash first time around, personally think Steer will be fine. RDL I agree should be a solid option at this level. Gardner I guess fine as 4th choice but depends on how much he earns and whether there's someone in our U23's who is at least as capable, which I think there is in Doyle-Hayes and Lyden, so would let him go. Therefore I'd definitely want to keep Gil and RDL if possible.
    • Bob Marley Buffalo Soldiers The Buffalo Soldiers where not Rastas 
    • If we manage to keep the core of the team and sign the better loan players no reason we cannot win the league.  Grealish only played half a season and Kodija a few games.  Keep Bruce. If we have to sell a few to balance the books and rely on bringing the youth players through then you need a new manager. I think this team would have got top 2 without the injuries to key players and add in the fact the teams coming down are no great shakes and 2 of the best teams Wolves and Fulham went up there is nothing to fear.   No reason we cannot sign Snoddy and Johnson.  Amavi money and the saving on Gabbys wages should cover the chunk of that.  Bree to replace Hutton.  Elphick to partner Chester saving Terrys wages. Kodija to replace Grabben.  OHare for Onomah. It sounds easy it's probably not but if that did happen and we keep Jack you would want Bruce to manage.