• limpid

      Just visiting?   27/12/16

      Please click "Sign Up" and login to use the full functionality of the site.

VillaTalk blog

  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Contributors to this blog

Player Match Ratings: The Late Show with Villa Jack!

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0


This forgettable game was settled by an unforgettable winning goal from Jack Grealish in the 88th minute.

Wigan came to Villa Park with limited ambition. They came to frustrate and to claim a point as will other teams as we climb further up the table this season. We started the game well and finished it even better but for over an hour this match appeared to have goalless draw written all over it until Jack struck with his stunning late goal. It is so nice to be scoring late goals rather than conceding them now!   

We lacked movement up front from forwards who were starved of service by a midfield that lacked creativity. Wigan worked hard, got men behind the ball and on those occasions when this did not prove sufficient resorted to making strong/illegal challenges particularly on Jack Grealish and Jonathan Kodjia in an attempt to keep them both quiet. That worked pretty effectively for them during the first 87 minutes until we went ahead and claimed our fourth successive home win to move just 3 points off the play-off places.       

We bounced back from defeat at Leeds as we so needed to do yesterday. We did not win with a swagger but successful teams win games when they are some way off their very best and this we did. I hope we also began another lengthy unbeaten or dare we hope a winning run yesterday? That will be put to the test at Norwich in midweek and at QPR next weekend.  

My player ratings from a game that we collected only our second home win in nine league games against yesterday’s visitors are:

Pierluigi Gollini – 6 – A very, very quiet day at the office. Could have sat on a deck chair in the goalmouth for most of this game but it was not really the weather for that.     

Alan Hutton – 6 – Worked hard and looked solid at the back if something less than a threat when moving into the Wigan half.   

James Chester - 6 – Another solid and composed performance on a day when our defence was seldom tested.       

Tommy Elphick – 6 – Tommy eased through this game with little cause for concern being provided by the visitors. That might not have been the case had Wigan been a little more adventurous and started the game with or introduced late substitute Will Grigg earlier than they did.

Jordan Amavi – 7 – Another encouraging display. He looks so confident and effective defensively of late and poses a threat when getting forward as he has always done. Clipped an effort just past the post on 7 minutes from inside of the box and Jaaskelainen dived low to his right to gather a shot from outside of the box 4 minutes later after he had picked up a loose ball from a corner.

Albert Adomah – 5 – Failed to make the same sort of positive impression on this game that he has done in others lately.    

Gary Gardner - 5 – Put in a shift as he always does prior to his substitution but he has it in him to impose himself more upon opponents.

Mile Jedinak – 6 – Another solid midfield display. Opponents must feel like they have run into a brick wall when they are challenged by Mile. Hit a shot from the edge of the box on 72 minutes straight at Jaaskelainen who gathered the ball easily enough.  

Jack Grealish – 7 – MOTM – Hit a spectacular winner to claim all three points for us in the 88th minute. A McCormack cross was headed out by a defender and picked up by Jack just outside the box. He then hit an unstoppable shot past Jaaskelainen and into the top right hand corner of the net.

Jordan Ayew – 4 – Jordan was disappointingly quiet again yesterday and needs to make a bigger impact on games like this. Lost the ball more than once and noticeably a couple of times near the end when we particularly needed to keep possession.

Jonathan Kodjia – 5 – Might have opened the scoring for us in the 14th minute when Adomah found him nicely inside the box but his attempted chip over Jaaskelainen was kept out by the keeper’s outstretched arm.        


Ross McCormack – 6 – Replaced Gardner on the hour and introduced a bit of much needed energy.  

Rudy Gestede – 4 - Replaced Adomah on 73 minutes. Rudy provided no threat up front and made little if any positive impression after coming off the bench.      

Leandro Bacuna – Replaced Jack in the 4th minute of stoppage time so he was not on long enough to gather any rating.

Up the Villa!

John Lewis

1 person likes this
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Posts

    • Chopped pork sandwich with sliced pickles and coleslaw, dipped in tangy BBQ sauce. For desert I had a quarter rack of ribs, same sauce. 
    • Sorry there's more, but this is it: If we wanted to be a better/more successful club or team, we should have shifted Gabby years ago and prioritised other players over him. Forget that he's a "villa lad" etc. Look at him as just a regular football player and you can see that he's not been at a level (at least technically) that is good enough for a club of our size and stature - even now!!! If we wanted to progress and challenge for honours, we required forwards with far superior skills but instead we stuck with Gabby and he has not paid back that "loyalty" with worthwhile or meaningful performances - ultimately, a complete and utter lack of goals or assists, which is frankly unforgivable.  For a so called striker, his goal scoring record is truly abysmal! Even if he had been played out of position at times (which I think was more due to his lack of reliability and skill that certain managers recognised but somehow were forced to fit him into the team, maybe because we had few or better alternatives or weren't willing to pay for them or replace him, for fear of fan discontent maybe?) Honestly, I don't & have never had any personal issues with the guy and wanted him to succeed when he was younger but this has gone on too long. Why did we or have we settled for such a player for so long?? He has just been a drain on the club in almost every sense and I honestly don't know how us fans at least have managed to put up with it. He genuinely offers next to nothing and it's so irritating that certain people get excited or defensive over him on the odd occasion he runs a bit harder and "harries" defenders. Come on now, that is absolutely ridiculous! That is not a skill or art and basic effort is the least we can ask of any player. Tell me, when was the last decent shot, decent pass, dribble etc etc. he did? Honestly, what does the guy offer? Can he do more than run around? And even if he manages to score the odd goal, it shouldn't excuse him. One goal and ppl will be praising him all over again, reserve the praise for the unlikely event that he manages a sustained run of quality performances with goals and assists -  it's incredibly unlikely that that will ever happen and why should he keep getting chances over and over again? How many occasions have we "hoped he would come good", over and over again and been let down every time... Come on, we are bigger and better than any one player.  
    • Eesh, can someone clean this mess up? Not a good sign..  
    • 1,280,000 RESULTSAny time New England Patriots 1st Seed AFC FOX Feb 5, 6:30 PM Super Bowl Atlanta Falcons 2nd Seed NFC Season stats 27.6   POINTS PER GAME   33.8     Data from STATS LLC © 2016 · All times are Eastern Standard Time
    • Ok, just wanted to make and elaborate on 2 simple points on Gabby, mainly as a way of releasing some long term frustration I have had with him and his whole situation. He really should've been shifted some time ago and has been a leech on the club - whether that was intentional or not. 1. Been at the club too long, career has massively stagnated and never progressed since early(?) MON days. Too much time wasted, too many chances, has always had overly preferential treatment from all, such low standards. Gets credit for doing nothing special or worthwhile, putting effort in should be a prerequisite for every player!! Does not have to do as much or perform as well as other players - never been as easily criticised as others just because of claims he is a boyhood fan. Has been way, way too long since he appeared to demonstrate that in any way, shape or form. 2. MON possibly ruined Gabby and he possibly lost some of his main qualities: pace & drive combined with finishing (had a great record for reserves and looked a decent young player) as he wanted to change his whole training methodology and wanted him to just bulk up and hold the ball up rather than be a pacy and impactful forward, like an inferior version of Owen for example. If he valued his football career and wanted to progress or improve his skills, he should have moved on (even just on loan) to a lower level club, change of environment may well have done him good. Too comfortable at Villa...could and should have reignited his career elsewhere and then maybe even have come back if he proved himself. Sadly that just hasn't been the case, I don't know when we will be rid of him, he will never come good and even the odd goal here or there would make no difference (at least to me), his record is absolutely appalling and I don't think he has ever been a beneficial personality or character to the squad and dressing room.
      Rant(?) over.
    • What a dreadful playoffs overall. 1 decent game. NFL is toast.
    • What is it with the wildlife in this place? Every bastard with teeth wants to just kill me, and they are not even hungry? Why cant I just shoot my gun in the air so these furry dickheads can just scurry back to their holes and leave me alone? I have got bird nests to raid, mushrooms to pick, rabbits to shoot, and other shit to do, without worrying about these hairy malicious asses as well.
    • I hope the reporter hasn't mis-judged Bruce taking the piss. It's reported as if he's lining up some potential wonder kid but it looks like they're taking it too literal.  P. S. What's with the Birmingham Mail? I live in North Wales and have done for a long time and used them as a decent read for info via their site for a few years. Then went cold turkey for a while and ever since I've read things since it's just like a crappy Facebook footy page posting rumour after rumour, nicking from other crap sources. Then the mail gets quoted by the rubbish blogs etc. What an absolute joke it is. These people are paid reporters too, just spouting shite from the Internet. I'm jealous.