Maybe it boils down to what people want to watch in a Football team.
I personally love to see someone finding the gaps that Ireland does, with a lot of creativity. Merson used to be my favourite player for example. Ireland's new found graft has added to his game as well.
Some people however, love watching players like Chris Herd. I think he's useful but that's not the top of my list.
In all fairness, I'm probably spouting absolute sh*t as it is a Friday afternoon, but I'm hoping you can see what I'm getting at!!!!