Jump to content

VillaTalk blog

  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Contributors to this blog

Player Match Ratings: A lacklustre display!




Newcastle will be unlikely to win many games away from home this season and we made it all too easy for them to claim the three points yesterday.

Too many of our players had an off day yesterday. We started off on the back foot and made it easy for the visitors to take and to retain the initiative. Having managed to draw level on 67 minutes there was some hope that we might go on to apply some sustained pressure and claim a win but that hope evaporated when we conceded another goal only six minutes later and we never really looked like pulling this one out of the fire.

We appear to lack the ability to boss games which we start as favourites and to keep a clean sheet in the league this being the 26th we have now gone without doing so. We lacked creativity and intensity yesterday often seeming devoid of ideas. Gabby missed a gaping open goal on a day that we created very few opportunities, we failed to compete strongly enough in the midfield and Newcastle eventually ran out worthy winners.

Last season we often went to home games with more than a touch of pessimism. A bright start to the season at Arsenal and Chelsea had left us approaching yesterday’s game with optimism despite our home defeat against Liverpool. But our hopes for three points were soon dashed by a second successive inept first half display that left us with a lot to do in the second half which again proved beyond us.

This second defeat at home to Newcastle was hard to take. This is a team that got a shot in the arm last season from their win against us and one that arrived with a simmering discontent given their lack of summer transfer activity. Had we claimed the first goal we could well have gone on to exploit that discontent and to be sitting comfortably in the top half of the table this morning. But our first half display did for us and we have now followed that encouraging first day victory at Arsenal with three league defeats one unluckily but the last two increasingly less so. The points gained from that early win have now been negated by two consecutive home defeats and although we still have three more points than we had got from the corresponding fixtures last season losing at home to Newcastle is a habit we did not want to start getting into and we will now need a win at Norwich to make amends for this debacle.

My player ratings from a game that has left us in the bottom six that we have grown far too accustomed to spending time in of late are:

Brad Guzan – 6 – Turned a Ben Arfa shot from the edge of the box past the post for a corner on 60 minutes but he could only parry a very similar effort 13 minutes later to Gouffran whose tap in proved the match winner.

Matt Lowton – 5 – Got forward well enough on those occasions he moved forward but left a hole behind him when we lost possession and was undone by Remy in the lead up to their opener and caught flat footed for the second.

Ron Vlaar – 6 – The most solid of our defenders yesterday.

Jores Okore – 6 – Injured in winning a challenge with Remy inside the box becoming the third of our central defenders to leave the field injured during our first four league games on the half hour mark. His ability to read the game was missed on a day when our defence was put under significant pressure.

Antonio Luna - 5 – Allowed Ben Arfa the space to cut inside rather than force him wide for their second and was given a tough defensive examination throughout. Really needed to try a shot rather than look for a pass when in room inside the box on 50 minutes and did not get forward as often or as effectively as he has been doing up until now.

Karim El Ahmadi – 3 – This was a disappointing return to the ineffective performances that led him to spend so much of last season out of the team. It will be a big surprise if Sylla does not start the next game after this.

Fabian Delph – 7 – MOTM – The best of our midfield by some distance and our most effective player on an ineffective day. Hit a 30 yard shot just wide on 80 minutes and having earlier picked up his customary booking.

Ashley Westwood – 5 – This was some way below the level of performance we have come to expect from Ash.

Gabriel Agbonlahor- 4 – Missed a game changing opportunity on 55 minutes. Lowton found Weimann whose splendid cross left Gabby with a tap in from a couple of yards out which he inexplicably hit across the gaping goal and wide. Fought back for the ball on those occasions he was dispossessed but his woeful miss capped off a below par display.

Andreas Weimann – 4 – Andi was some way off his best on his return from international duty yesterday and looked weary at times. Pulled a shot badly wide on 42 minutes having been found well by Lowton might possibly have been distracted by thoughts of squaring the ball to Gabby.

Christian Benteke – 6 – Powered in a header from a corner on 67 minutes to bring us all square. The test of a great striker is to score on a day when they appear to be having an off day. Benteke was not at his dominant best, lacked service and did not hold the ball up as well as he usually does. But he averages a goal a game and where on earth would we be without his goals?


Ciaran Clark – 6 - Replaced Okore on 30 minutes and gave a good account of himself at the back. Hit a first time shot into the side netting after Krul had flapped at a Lowton cross on 41 minutes.

Libor Kozak – 5 - Replaced El Ahmadi on 67 minutes. His introduction at the corner that led to our goal may have led to some confusion in the Newcastle defence which Benteke benefited from. Early days in the shirt and had limited service and opportunity to shine.

Aleksandar Tonev - Replaced Weimann on 88 minutes. Not on long enough to earn a rating.

Up the Villa!

John Lewis

Source: Player Match Ratings: A lacklustre display!



Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

  • Posts

    • O Wijndal would be a good signing
    • I interpreted this as they are yet to trust themselves/believe that they can achieve the things hai team are telling them they can. Anyone who has been part of evolving/changing a work culture will know some buy in faster than others. Sometimes the people who take longer might be the biggest champions once they get there.
    • I was thinking to myself again after the game today that (ironically enough given they are struggling) I love Leicester’s model… buy players, some on big money, but assume it will take a year for them to be up and running. As long as Buendia, Bailey etc are firing next season (and to be clear I think they’ll be firing well before then) then next summer’s signings go into that pipeline as well and can be eased in. That doesn’t work if you’re scrapping against relegation and need immediate results but hopefully that won’t be us again any time soon.
    • I think this whole thing has been overblown. One of the journos cleared it up and said the story was basically he has a deal to the summer of 2023 and wants to break into the team before he signs an extension, but as there are 18 months to run no-one has an issue. 
    • Hope we smash these lot 10-0. Trezeguet with all 10 goals.
    • Calm cool collective on the ball. He will become a monster of a player under Gerrard. Looking forward to seeing him more against Norwich and Burnley
    • He's looking increasingly comfortable which is a good sign. Mugging off Maddison was a great way to top off a decent little cameo.
    • He's getting there for sure. Gets caught dithering or taking an extra touch a bit too often right now, but I think that's a combination of both him and the team itself still clicking. Even Gerrard himself constantly hammers home the point about the team being a work in progress in terms of possession and I think you can see this in the good and bad of Buendia. When he gets it right he pulls off some majestic stuff and generally gets moves flowing better than most. Can't fault the work off the ball either given the type of player he is.
    • Creative attackers almost always take time to bed in to a new team and environment!! Look at Grealish himself, undoubtedly one of the best players in the division and struggling to adapt to life at City. Bernardo Silva is currently the second best player in the world after Salah and if you lot were his manager in his first season at City you would have sent him back to Portugal 😂😂 Leo bloody Messi, the best player in the entire **** history of football, has moved to a new club for the first time in his career and has only 1 goal all season - you guys would probably be binning him off too. FMD the number of people on here who think real life football is FIFA and you can just plug a player into a team and expect 100% output from day one absolutely astounds me.
    • There’s a 60-70m player in there.  Hope as he gets more comfortable with the system and the players around him the penchant for misplaced midfield passes/caught in possession becomes a thing of the past. He’s incredibly unselfish with his play and also has a bit of a prick about him which I personally love.  Always looking to create for others and always pressing defensively.  Can see why Stevie likes him.

  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of use Terms of Use, Cookies We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.