Just because it was a red doesnt mean we were robbed. We wouldn't necessarily have gone on to win and its often more difficult to play again 10 men, as we found out as gainst them at Villa Park in the league a few weeks back.
It was too easy for United, we very rarely looked threatening.
Yes but it was a central defender. We saw Blackburn collapse at VP when Samba was sent off and Manure would've had to take a midfielder off to bring on another defender so they'd have lost the midfield dominance.
And they'd have needed to score with 10 men so played right into our hands.
I don't think United would collapse like that, especially with Rooney on the field aswell, they'd still have been a massive threat, and it's often harder playing against a team that has just had a player sent off.
Vidic should have gone, fair enough, but I think it's being used as a bit of an excuse and almost as if had Dowd shown him the red, we'd have gone on to win!
We could have played for another 90 minutes yesterday and we probably still wouldnt have scored against them with 11. We made it easy for them, evening during spells during the first and second periods where we had a lot of the ball, we didn't look threatening.
Well Rooney wasn't on the field at that point!
I just see it logically as Manure would've needed to score with 1 less player (and for all their domination at VP, they didn't actually score with 10 men).
Obviously with it still being 11 v 11 Manure proved they were the better side but it shouldn't have been that.