Richard you cant compare the Ellis out and DOL out stances as the same sort of thing. Replacements for DOL are there for people to debate about, replacements in the world of business are not in the public domain so you cant really form an opinion, IMO.
The reason I think he's the right manager for us now is based a lot on the fact that he's in the job now. Its a bit of damage limitation as it stands at the moment and I dont think his record as a manager is as bad as some would have us believe. Its a tough job managing Villa and some of the best have tried and somewhat failed. Circumstances at the club have got worse, so we need stability, both from a personnel point of view and from a financial point of view. Getting rid of DOL now would, again IMO, impact both of these in a negative way.
As one of the posters above said, we all know who the key to most of the issues at the club is, so that would be in an ideal world the first replacement. DOL is not the best, I will admit that and he has made mistakes and will probably do so again. But AVFC dont find themselves in the luxurious position where it can afford to take many gambles.
I still think DOL can and will do a good job for us (EDIT: sorry pressed submit before I could add this)