No it isn't. Managers have philosophies, how many managers in the game do you see change their way they manage clubs regularly depending on their club?
Martinez doesn't get Wigan playing like Barca but he certainly gives a passing game a go because that's his style.
McLeish is a very negative manager and it wouldn't change here. Maybe not to the extent, just like when O'Neill was at Leicester, we'd just see a slightly better game, mainly because we have better playes. We wouldn't see a change of style though from what McLeish usually manages.
David Moyes uses negative tactics, so does Rafa Benitez - but i see loads of people wanting them here?? Whats the difference?
Oh thats right...he managed blues.
The difference is he managed to get Blues relegated twice, in 3 years. This is not good enough and no amount of excuses can justify that. He is not good enough for where we want to be and it is as simple as that. If the likes of Hughes & Benitez weren't available and willing to join us then McLeish maybe a viable option but he has not performed well at Birmingham.
I fail to see how some people think that winning the League Cup, after a massive blunder by Arsenal's goalie, and then getting relegated whilst playing god awful football is some kind of achievement that we should covet at our club.