I'm considering this as well, because I seem to curse players with bad form/injury when I get their names on the back of my shirt.
2010/11 - Agbonlahor: poor season plagued by injuries
2011/12 - Bent: out injured from February onwards
2012/13 - Vlaar: spent a lot of time injured
2013/14 - Benteke: don't even need to elaborate on this
I've only ever had 3 names on my shirts.
Earl Barratt
Savo Milosovic
Juan Pablo Angel
(Not sure if spelling is correct)
Either way, they left that season