Jump to content

VillaTalk blog

  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Contributors to this blog

Player Match Ratings: Villa battle back for a Desmond



We extended our unbeaten run to 7 games yesterday and Stoke’s own unbeaten run now stands at 9.

The deluge in which the game was played was not conducive to flowing football and both teams cancelled each other out in the first half. The goals like the weather were not going to dry up though and the second half rained goals.

I had feared that the visitors might extend their run of victories at Villa Park to 4 each time they went ahead but we are made of sterner stuff than we once were, now aren’t we? A draw was a fair result on a day that we were not able to reproduce the level of performances that we have been producing of late, in a game during which we so clearly missed Jack’s invention in and around the visitor’s box.     

The visitors started strongly, were well organised, gave us little space and were allowed to make several uncompromising challenges in order to break up our forward movement. They came to stifle us and to get a point. They might have taken all three had we not battled back twice from a goal behind. This was a point that may well prove crucial when the season reaches its conclusion against a team that unlike us currently, have both a solid goalkeeper and a solid defence.  

We now face a second tough home game against the current league leaders on Sunday. They are currently 12 points ahead of us and we could do with a win to bring that gap down to single figures and to leave us with realistic ambitions of finishing the season above them in one of the automatic places.

My player ratings from a game that kept us two points ahead of our fellow promotion chasers from the Potteries are:

Orjan Nyland – 6 – Saved well from Allen low at his left-hand post on 6 minutes. Parried away an 11th minute shot from McLean from a Martina cross and Chester hooked the resultant loose ball clear. For some reason dropped a knee when Allen put Stoke ahead on 47 minutes and the ball flew over his outstretched arm into the net. Went the right way for Afobe’s well hit 78th minute penalty but the ball was destined for the left-hand corner of his net.            

Ahmed Elmohamady – 5 – Allowed McLean to run inside him and then unnecessarily brought him down inside the box with Kodjia covering the run ahead of the forward.    

James Chester - 6 – Solid enough and looked nearer to his reliable best.       

Axel Tuanzebe – 6 – Becoming more familiar with and showing signs of growing into the role alongside Chester.            

Alan Hutton – 6 – Lost possession on the edge of the box to McLean whose cross was hit home by Allen for the visitor’s first. Looked better when moving forward than when under pressure at the back from Ince. He’s got to start on the right whenever possible.     

Glenn Whelan – 6 – Did all that can be expected of him. He is not a like for like replacement for Jack, but he did put in a shift.

Anwar El Ghazi – 4 – So disappointing following his display last week. Had little of the ball and did little with it on those rare occasions that he did have it. Was unable to force home a Hutton cross on 55 minutes from close range that Butland gathered gratefully.    

Conor Hourihane – 6 – Butland helped Conor’s 24th minute free-kick from just outside of the area over the bar.       

John McGinn – 7 – Got stuck in and was our stand out player until the arrival of Jonny Danger. Missed the space that opponent’s double teaming and focus on Jack normally provides as did others.             

Yannick Bolasie – 6 – Blasted the ball harmlessly over the bar on 80 minutes when a cross seemed a much better option. Hit a shot wide of the post on 61 minutes from inside of the box. Claimed an assist with a nice cross for our second and it was nice to see him playing a full game.

Tammy Abraham – 7 – Had a 55th minute shot from the edge of the area saved low by Butland at a post. Was made to wait a long time to take our 73rd minute penalty but he coolly slotted it home sending Butland the wrong way in the process. 


Jonathan Kodjia – 8 – MOTM - Replaced El Ghazi on 65 minutes and what a difference he made! Was pulled back inside the box by Pieters as he moved to Elmo’s ball to him which resulted in our penalty. Headed home our second equalizer on 84 minutes when he headed a Bolasie cross pat Butland and into the left-hand corner of his net.       

Scott Hogan – Replaced Whelan on 85 minutes. Not on long enough to gather a rating.   

Up the Villa & A Merry Christmas to all Villa Talkers!

John Lewis


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

  • Posts

    • I saw absolutely nothing from Wesley to suggest he would be adequate as a Premier League 10. It's up front or not at all.
    • Seems a bit more nuance to this than the Suarez situation. Doesn't seem like he was abusing the person like Suarez was. I guess someone who speaks Spanish can confirm, but people are saying N*grito can be used as a term of endearment.
    • I'd like to think our only concerns will be whether they'll play, how the team who wants them plays and their quality of coaching. I agree that it could be a good idea to get them out together. Most of the loanees from the clubs you name only had high loan fees as they were bought with 1st team experience or had successful loan spells in the past. We'd only get pennies for youngsters and I can't see it being worth holding out for a bit more money.
    • It's going to be a fascinating window with work permit restrictions to be extended to EU players. I'm dubious there will be a workable solution by the end of January, which would mean no more bargains from Europe, an even higher homegrown premium and probably very little business. I'm sure the PL have put proposals forwards, but the Home Office are likely to be more concerned with sorting out next summers' fruit pickers than footballers for now. There was talk of a fixed transfer fee of £15m+ being enough for a WP, which means PL teams looking for first team signings wont suffer too much although teams like Brentford will be badly hit. It could actually be less restrictive for non-EU signings if the rumours of us paying £22m for Wesley just to get a WP are true. There are some good talents in Scotland that get sold for next to nothing right now, so it wouldn't surprise me to see more PL clubs taking a punt and considerably more money going in to the Scottish league.
    • We just have to ensure, we don't get beat.......for momentum and confidence.
    • I don't think we fear anyone, but ourselves. If the right Villa Team turn up, we will be ok.
    • Yeah, I had a Tangerine Dream CD years ago which I appear to have lost, but then I sort of rediscovered Popul Vuh on a couple of those Elektronische compilation albums that Sounds of the Universe do (couldn’t get vol 4, I was too slow). It’s a tricky area, I appear to love the Krautrock and the German experimentation around that time. But I’m allergic to noodling prog rock. Somehow, I think they manage to stay the right side of a fine line.  
    • Fulham had a really nice midfield in those days with likes of him and Steed Malbranque who was also on the wishlist most transfer windows.
    • Papa Boupa Diop. RIP Was such a powerhouse running through midfield. I always wanted Villa to sign someone like him back in the 2000s

  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of use Terms of Use, Cookies We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.