Reo-Coker should be given a man marking role on Gerrard.
If Sidwell and say Delph can then tight to the other two midfielders, we can really stop them playing, I'd play Luke Young at right back, Beye at left back, mainly because I think Young is a better defender and will be copying with Beanayoun, while Beye is taller for any crosses at the back post towards Kuyt.
Milner should play on the left, given the task of keeping Glen Johnson quiet, although Ash works hard, I think he'd get stuck defending the whole game and wouldn't get him on the ball up the pitch and also Johnson has the beating of Young whenever i've seen them play each other.
let Young play on the right or even Albrighton and use Ash Young as one of the 3 in midfield, i.e Coker - Sidwell and Young....playing Carew upfront, especially if that Ayala plays, as he can look to bully him.