Given: 7 Kept us in the match
Hutton: 5 Improved in the second half but still a utter liability, could have had a straight red!
Collins: 5 Defended ok 90% of the time but that 10% usually means a goal for the other team, thank God Lita is shite!
Dunne: 6 Too many rash/needless challenges but otherwise ok!
Warnock: 6 Was often out best hope going fwd and was ok but by no means great defending
Delph: 4 I lost count how many times he gave possession away or miscontrolled the ball, was better in the first half but still incapable of a fwd pass
Herd: 5 Better than Delph but again just passes backwards or sideways.
Heskey: 4 - I just don't understand what he offers the team, he doesn't track back, he wins a few headers is clueless going forward WTF!
Nzogbia: 5 - Seems to have got worse from the last few starts he made, loses possession too easily and has no final ball
Gabby: 8 - Our only credible threat - was great again today
Bent: 5 - Starved of service but when he did get some he didn't come even close
subs: Jenas 6 - Looks tidier and reads the game well - looks so much better than Herd or Delph
Bannan 7 - every pass opened up Swansea and was a fwd ball, has to start simple as that.
Eck: 4 - Swansea away should not be a game we are scared of losing and yet thats how he sets up the team.