Got to be Pro Evo, easily the most realistic. Im personally not really arsed about editing players as long as it plays well. The rumour is, it plays slower than pro evo 5. But even from the ISS days, whenever a new one has come out it always appears different and slower at the start, but after a few games you adjust. The only areas of real concern for me would be the live option. For some reason pro evo 5 was at times difficult to get a game. Secondly i feel they could improve on the league for live players, which i believe Fifa have done. In any case i'll still be at game 27th October!!!!