Giants
1. Who do you realistically want to take?
I'm happy to not take a QB at #2 or to trade the pick and move down, but only slightly and for significant compensation.
It looks like all the trade talk surrounding Odell Beckham has quietened down now, so if he can get his head together and the rumours around Dez Bryant are true, then for me the logical selection at #2 has to be Saquon Barkley to give the offense some signigicant playmaking ability across the board. I am far from an expert but the production, highlights and measurables are all there with this kid and by all accounts he seems to be a good egg.
I think Saquon is better than all the recent great RB draft picks such as Fournette, Gurley, Elliot etc as he will be more of a factor catching the ball out the backfield.
If we trade down then i wouldnt want to move out of the top 5 to ensure we could get Nelson or Chubb. If we move past 4 then i suspect Saquon will go to the Browns there if not #1 overall, but i think the Browns will take their preferred QB of the bunch there.
2. Who do you think you will ACTUALLY take?
John Mara flew out to have dinner with Josh Rosen, so i think he is a possibility. The Giants have scouted Barkley significantly and spent plenty of time with the main QB's also. They had Chubb in for a visit as well, so it depends how Cleveland go with the #1 pick and who might be willing to come up.
3. Who do you think might fall to your spot who you would take instead?
Tough to answer as pretty much everyone is a possibility when picking number 2 overall!
I like Josh Allen as a prospect but not at #2 overall. If he falls to the second round i would be intrigued about picking him up to sit behind Eli for a few seasons, but i think that is unlikely and expect he goes higher in the draft potentially #1 overall! Completion percentage/accuracy being the main concern for this guy.
4. Who do you want to completely avoid?
Josh Rosen. On the one hand i think he could be the best QB in the draft, but my concern is around his durability and the concussion history.