Jump to content

Laivasse

Full Member
  • Posts

    1,416
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Laivasse

  1. Just now, penguin said:

    Agree. Reminds me of Huth all season. Will charge the ball with his arms outstretched, making himself a big an obstacle as possible, so when the ball hits one its technically not 'deliberate' but hes sure as hell is getting an advantage from it. The rules need further detail I think.

    That last one was far more nailed on than the first shout. Landing from an aerial challenge with your arms up is arguably a 'natural' position, but charging to block a ball with your elbows flared just gives the ball more chance of pinging off them, penalty all day imo.

    • Like 1
  2. I was rooting for the underdogs, but to be fair if you play for penalties you usually don't win and that's deserved. They showed they could play, so they had to try and go for it at some point earlier than the 24th minute of extra time.

     

    Massive credit to them for getting to the QF though.

  3. Brazil have been cynical and shit, but for me Colombia just haven't done enough. Terrible decision making and delivery in the final third. Would have loved to see them progress but they just didn't earn it in this game. Brazil had 2 good set pieces, Colombia offered very little to speak of.

    • Like 1
  4. This is a bit shit. Isn't physical endurance part of the test as to who the better team is?

     

    My thoughts exactly. Also it seems dubious to me that 15 minutes further exertion in heat like this would present a serious health hazard. A 'break' is what half time is for.

     

    As Hoddle implied, this all just seems like a trial run for the even greater heat in Qatar.

  5. Brazil fully deserved to get through, they were the only team looking to win in the second half and extra time. Chile contributed to a wonderful first half of football but got more negative as the game went on. 

     

    I thought Chile came closest in ET with that shot thundered onto the bar.

  6. Bradley still looking like a college player

     

    It's strange because I actually rated him a little and think he didn't get a fair shake at Villa. Having not watched him in a while and now seeing him at this WC, he looks utter wank.

  7.  

     

    Surely that makes it even worse? He kicked Dempsey in the face whilst both were jumping, how is that not dangerous play?

     

    his leg came up because of the contact after he'd left the ground, he's going horizontal in mid air, its not his jumping technique thats caused his leg to come up, its dempsey jumping in to him, not sure what else he could do

     

     

    I understand it's not intentional, and I'm not saying he should have been sent off, but if you're kicking someone in the face, it's dangerous play. Yes, he gets a nudge, but he could try control his leg better, his leg goes so far up because it's already swinging upwards before the nudge, he's completely uncontrolled and reckless, therefore it's dangerous.

     

     

    Dangerous play refers to an intentional move that happens to be dangerous. There's no such thing as unintentional dangerous play from a rules standpoint. For instance if a player successfully challenges for a header and clashes heads very hard with a player he didn't see, then that's literally 'dangerous play' but the term would be meaningless in that context. Much the same for a normal kick that turns into a high leg because you've been shoved backwards.

×
×
  • Create New...
Â