banny73

In all fairness, you have to give credit to those who wanted him out at the end of last season, still wanting him out now.

At least they're not fickle.

I would also guess that at some point in the season, should we be up there challenging, they may have to reassess their stance ...

No, they're not fickle, just thick

No way, most over rated player i can remember,that was years ago, he can only have got worse

P.S - if the mods were to stick a poll on this I rather suspect laursen1977 you would be out voted about 20 to 1 on this subject.

I think so too. I know what you're sayin re stats, but to have the option of carew in the last few games would have been a great help. Yes i know we haven't been beaten in 9, but as someone else posted, who's to say we would have done even better with him in the team??

Let me ask this question then......If we haven't missed him, or we don't need him, who would sell him in jan window??

Nearer flop than hero.

9.5 mill years ago we should have got more return on him. Skillful little player just not robust enough for the prem. Never scored against the big teams neither. Looked good against the weaker teams.

The word hero should be kept for players in the class of Sir Paul McGrath, Gary Shaw, Sid Cowans etc

To tune of MC Hammer - Can't touch this

Na na na na, Na na, Na na James Milner

:shock: