Jump to content
Adblockers - please click ×
Sign in to follow this  
dudevillaisnice

Jean II Makoun

Recommended Posts

err said im not having a go at gh but if you feel jm can produce impacts like v.d.vart of spurs or adams of blackpool then thats fine,i feel jm is not what we need right now,we have paid ALOT of £ for a player "IMHO" is not ready for the prem,

Not sure where to start with this one? He looked good to me, got booked early and as a DM was always going to struggle thereafter on his debut, especially with the pace of the PL.

I reckon the £5 or 6m we paid will be good business, especially at the reputed £35K/week.

He is not an impact player like VdV, nor a creative like CA. CA will cost £10m at least in this window, VdV would cost £10m+ and an equivalent I would suggest would be £18+, but I don't know of any in this window?Wages for VdV or CM will be on another planet to JM.

We were shipping goals like no-one business prior to JM's transfer and with NRC likely to be off its replacing one with a potentially better one. He will take four games to get up to speed, but I reckon we are going to love this boy.

Finally, I reckon RL would have bought an CM, aswell as JM if one was around for the right money, so I don't believe its a case of one or the other. We have plenty of creativity in the current squad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oh and your dreaming if you think Charlie Adam will come here for £5m..
no mate..lets say we had the jm £7mil plus davis £ today ...were close on £10mil..that would be enough to see adams in a villa shirt,i think adams would make a impact now,this is what villa need like darren bent,hes wasnt cheap but hes ready now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oh and your dreaming if you think Charlie Adam will come here for £5m..
no mate..lets say we had the jm £7mil plus davis £ today ...were close on £10mil..that would be enough to see adams in a villa shirt,i think adams would make a impact now,this is what villa need like darren bent,hes wasnt cheap but hes ready now.

Would they want Davies? £7m for Adam? I still don't see it.. Holloway would want much more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oh and your dreaming if you think Charlie Adam will come here for £5m..
no mate..lets say we had the jm £7mil plus davis £ today ...were close on £10mil..that would be enough to see adams in a villa shirt,i think adams would make a impact now,this is what villa need like darren bent,hes wasnt cheap but hes ready now.

Would they want Davies? £7m for Adam? I still don't see it.. Holloway would want much more.

what im saying is i see jm a player not ready & at £7mill that £ could have been spent on adams who is ready & with the davis £ gh would have £10mil..theirs your adams £

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

DVIN look at his image a certain MON picture, he's used to over paying for players.
lets see if jh can finish 6 from top matey :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

JM was 5 million euros.. I understand what you are saying however £4.2m + £3m (davies?) = £7.2m... which again is £7m.. I honestly think even if we coughed up the money Holloway would say no.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh and your dreaming if you think Charlie Adam will come here for £5m..
no mate..lets say we had the jm £7mil plus davis £ today ...were close on £10mil..that would be enough to see adams in a villa shirt,i think adams would make a impact now,this is what villa need like darren bent,hes wasnt cheap but hes ready now.

Makoun was closer to £4-5 million. How is Adam worth £10 million? What's he done, compared to Makoun?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oh and your dreaming if you think Charlie Adam will come here for £5m..
no mate..lets say we had the jm £7mil plus davis £ today ...were close on £10mil..that would be enough to see adams in a villa shirt,i think adams would make a impact now,this is what villa need like darren bent,hes wasnt cheap but hes ready now.

Makoun was closer to £4-5 million. How is Adam worth £10 million? What's he done, compared to Makoun?

Proved he can play in the premiership? (granted its only been 6 months but still).

Ill judge Makoun after a few more games. Everyone thinks he is a world beater on here, ill believe it when I see it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oh and your dreaming if you think Charlie Adam will come here for £5m..
no mate..lets say we had the jm £7mil plus davis £ today ...were close on £10mil..that would be enough to see adams in a villa shirt,i think adams would make a impact now,this is what villa need like darren bent,hes wasnt cheap but hes ready now.

Makoun was closer to £4-5 million. How is Adam worth £10 million? What's he done, compared to Makoun?

Proved he can play in the premiership? (granted its only been 6 months but still).

Ill judge Makoun after a few more games. Everyone thinks he is a world beater on here, ill believe it when I see it.

Adam has proved he can play in the Prem for 6 months with Blackpool while Makoun has played in the Champions League and impressed in that competition and has a good reputation as a good player. I know out of Adam - £10 million, Makoun - £5 million, which one I'd want.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Oh and your dreaming if you think Charlie Adam will come here for £5m..
no mate..lets say we had the jm £7mil plus davis £ today ...were close on £10mil..that would be enough to see adams in a villa shirt,i think adams would make a impact now,this is what villa need like darren bent,hes wasnt cheap but hes ready now.

Makoun was closer to £4-5 million. How is Adam worth £10 million? What's he done, compared to Makoun?

Proved he can play in the premiership? (granted its only been 6 months but still).

Ill judge Makoun after a few more games. Everyone thinks he is a world beater on here, ill believe it when I see it.

Adam has proved he can play in the Prem for 6 months with Blackpool while Makoun has played in the Champions League and impressed in that competition and has a good reputation as a good player. I know out of Adam - £10 million, Makoun - £5 million, which one I'd want.

Just curious, is that proved he can play in the Prem like Sidwell did at Reading?

And I'd have the player with Prem experience in the situation we were and still are in, experience in this league counts for more right now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh and your dreaming if you think Charlie Adam will come here for £5m..
no mate..lets say we had the jm £7mil plus davis £ today ...were close on £10mil..that would be enough to see adams in a villa shirt,i think adams would make a impact now,this is what villa need like darren bent,hes wasnt cheap but hes ready now.

Makoun was closer to £4-5 million. How is Adam worth £10 million? What's he done, compared to Makoun?

Proved he can play in the premiership? (granted its only been 6 months but still).

Ill judge Makoun after a few more games. Everyone thinks he is a world beater on here, ill believe it when I see it.

Adam has proved he can play in the Prem for 6 months with Blackpool while Makoun has played in the Champions League and impressed in that competition and has a good reputation as a good player. I know out of Adam - £10 million, Makoun - £5 million, which one I'd want.

Just curious, is that proved he can play in the Prem like Sidwell did at Reading?

And I'd have the player with Prem experience in the situation we were and still are in, experience in this league counts for more right now.

Well in a way, different players. Adam should be better suited to last long term but nothing is proven. I mean, worth a punt for £4 millon ish, £10 million though? having a laugh.

Makoun has performed in the Champions League and against teams like Real Madrid, Man United...which I'd count for just as important as 20 Premiership matches.

I don't see any sort of 'situation' we're in right now. I'd also say Adam has been playing in a team that is expressive and just goes for it, plays football, how would he of coped in a team say a little more nervous, little less 'free' so to speak, lots of pressure to perform etc...Out of both of them, I think Makoun will prove to be the better player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Adam will be forgotten soon. He is having a good season but as people have previously said. So did Sidwell. Makoun is proven at the highest level for several seasons. No comparison IMO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...
Â