Jump to content

Ratings and Reactions: Villa - Cardiff


limpid

Man of the match  

96 members have voted

  1. 1. Who was your man of the match?

    • Guzan
      0
    • Bacuna
      80
    • Clark
      3
    • Westwood
      0
    • Vlaar
      7
    • Baker
      0
    • El Ahmadi
      0
    • Tonev
      1
    • Benteke
      0
    • Kozak
      5
    • Sylla
      0
    • Lowton (for El Ahmadi 74)
      0
    • Bowery (for Kozak 88)
      0


Recommended Posts

 

 

Now I have finished celebrating, I can be honest about that game.

We were god-awful. As bad as we have been in any game in the last year. Nothing but hoofing for 75 minutes. Abject stuff. Cardiff are one of the worst PL teams I've ever seen and we struggled to beat them. Yes Kozak nearly scored early second half and Benteke could have done better a few times but it was a terrible performance. A moment of magic won us the game.

I dont why we have regressed in terms of the football we play but its awful to watch.

Excellent result though so we're happy but the underlying problems are plentiful and getting worse.

I kind of agree - but that formation does, I believe give us something to build on - Steady Defence, Tonev wide, and Kozak as a battering ram. I beleive that has more mileage than Gabby, Weimann, Benteke - in that narrow formation.

The problem was tonev whipped in two good crosses in the first half that needed someone running to the near post, the anticipation was non existent when it comes to attacking crosses

 

 

Crosses going in - but no one being on the end of them is progress in my book !!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Take three points all day long but the performance was dreadful.

Eh missing several important players Cardiff created absolutely nothing at all. If anyone was going to win it was going to be Villa, and that's what happened.

 

So you want to contradict my point by stating it was a good performance?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

10761499275_ce40c29e2b_o.gif

Bacuna really fooled the GK with this one. I don't know if it's his body shape when approaching the ball but it caused the GK to move to his right. MOTM for making the difference today.

 

It had so much bend and dip I personally think it just completely flummoxed him!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Now I have finished celebrating, I can be honest about that game.

 

We were god-awful. As bad as we have been in any game in the last year. Nothing but hoofing for 75 minutes. Abject stuff. Cardiff are one of the worst PL teams I've ever seen and we struggled to beat them. Yes Kozak nearly scored early second half and Benteke could have done better a few times but it was a terrible performance. A moment of magic won us the game.

 

I dont why we have regressed in terms of the football we play but its awful to watch.

 

Excellent result though so we're happy but the underlying problems are plentiful and getting worse.

Personally the tactics were hardley surprising when you consider who we had up top! Thought we defended well and shut them out well.  Going forward and in terms of keeping possesion you are completely right, but our style of play was right for the players on the pitch.  Workman like midfield massive strike force, the only option is hit it long really!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Poor first half, Cardiff came for a draw and for a long while it looked like they might get it. Lambert moving Bacuna forward was a smart move and he showed desire with that one two and run leading to the free kick which was something special.

Ratings:

Guzan 7 commanded area

Vlaar 7 solid

Clark 6 sliced the ball on occasions wasting possession

Baker 6 did ok

Bacuna 8 MOM see above

Tonev 6 was an outlet but crosses were wasteful

KEA 5 poor

Sylla 6 harried Cardiff high up the pitch

Westwood 6 tried forward thinking passes, didnt always come off

Benteke 6 often crowded out, touch is coming back but needs a goal

Kozak 7 came close with header and got reward for aerial threat caused with a goal

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still in Holte suite celebrating the win.

To be honest it was a crap game between two crap teams until that free kick. Nice to see us beat this type of team though :-)

 

I saw you schmoozing the door men with your 

 

we-need-you.jpg

 

T-Shirt on you big suck-up :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The booing at HT wound me up so much, our home crowd are a disgrace at times.

 Agree. I'd rather those that booed at half time when it was 0-0 stayed at home. Hardly surprising the players look edgy at times. Cardiff came to us on the back of a derby win with pretty much a fully fit squad whereas we had 5 key players unavailable.

 

Bacuna MOTM although Vlaar, Clark and Sylla were good. Can't understand the criticism of Sylla given that he's had limited game time. Both he and Benteke looked rusty so hopefully the 90 mins will do them both good.

 

Couldn't see the point of Bowery coming on. He's not a natural striker as he had a chance to pull the trigger when on goal, hesitated and passed instead. That's not the instinct of a natural striker. Wold've preferred Helenius to get a few more minutes as I feel he's a much better prospect at this level.

 

It's great to get 3 points but ironic that the performance against Everton was better but yielded nil points.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

10761499275_ce40c29e2b_o.gif

Bacuna really fooled the GK with this one. I don't know if it's his body shape when approaching the ball but it caused the GK to move to his right. MOTM for making the difference today.

 

It had so much bend and dip I personally think it just completely flummoxed him!

 

Phenomenal technique, it swerved and dipped a lot. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought we were rubbish until Bacuna rescued it - he would have been MotM without the free kick too - and it took moving him into our midfield to bring any life to it. I guess I learned that if we were to mysteriously lose Gabby, Weimann, Luna and Delph for the rest of the season, we'd probably go down and that Cardiff won't be far off it either. Thankfully that lot should be back soon and we've battled to a win without them. 

 

I think the defence are looking better, Bacuna has been very solid, Vlaar is in his best form since he arrived and Clark and Baker appear to be maturing. Up front, Kozak looks a player who'll give you what he's got; time will tell whether that's enough. Benteke will be fine when we start playing a bit more football.

 

Our midfield is a mess though, Bacuna was far and away our best midfielder and he was only there for fifteen minutes - KEA is probably our second best, which isn't saying much - I'm not convinced Westwood is a Premier league player and I'm not sure Sylla is either. With Delph in there we have something, but we could do with another one or two midfielders when we next get our money out.

 

Tonev remains possibly the least effective player I've seen - I think he touched the ball two or three time in the first half and at least two of those were attempted shots - he improved in the second half, but he's still a long way away from being a first team player for me.

 

Fair play to the manager, he got a win and a clean sheet out of a poor Villa side and he's made a good substitution to get us there - but this team needs players, some to come back from and injury and some new ones in the middle please.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

 

10761499275_ce40c29e2b_o.gif

Bacuna really fooled the GK with this one. I don't know if it's his body shape when approaching the ball but it caused the GK to move to his right. MOTM for making the difference today.

 

It had so much bend and dip I personally think it just completely flummoxed him!

 

Phenomenal technique, it swerved and dipped a lot. 

 

Absolutely right, look how low in the net it lands

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's great to get 3 points but ironic that the performance against Everton was better but yielded nil points.

 

 

 

Oddly enough, our season has been like this - I think Chelsea might have been our best performance, we were poor against Man City, poor today and decent against Everton. 

 

In a way, I like this - you never quite know what you're going to get.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Our midfield is a mess though, Bacuna was far and away our best midfielder and he was only there for fifteen minutes - KEA is probably our second best, which isn't saying much - I'm not convinced Westwood is a Premier league player and I'm not sure Sylla is either. With Delph in there we have something, but we could do with another one or two midfielders when we next get our money out.

 

 

This. We really need two CM's to play alongside Delph. The current bunch are second rate really.

 

Edited by villa89
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought we were rubbish until Bacuna rescued it - he would have been MotM without the free kick too - and it took moving him into our midfield to bring any life to it. I guess I learned that if we were to mysteriously lose Gabby, Weimann, Luna and Delph for the rest of the season, we'd probably go down and that Cardiff won't be far off it either. Thankfully that lot should be back soon and we've battled to a win without them. 

 

I think the defence are looking better, Bacuna has been very solid, Vlaar is in his best form since he arrived and Clark and Baker appear to be maturing. Up front, Kozak looks a player who'll give you what he's got; time will tell whether that's enough. Benteke will be fine when we start playing a bit more football.

 

Our midfield is a mess though, Bacuna was far and away our best midfielder and he was only there for fifteen minutes - KEA is probably our second best, which isn't saying much - I'm not convinced Westwood is a Premier league player and I'm not sure Sylla is either. With Delph in there we have something, but we could do with another one or two midfielders when we next get our money out.

 

Tonev remains possibly the least effective player I've seen - I think he touched the ball two or three time in the first half and at least two of those were attempted shots - he improved in the second half, but he's still a long way away from being a first team player for me.

 

Fair play to the manager, he got a win and a clean sheet out of a poor Villa side and he's made a good substitution to get us there - but this team needs players, some to come back from and injury and some new ones in the middle please.

 

Great post.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I guess I learned that if we were to mysteriously lose Gabby, Weimann, Luna and Delph for the rest of the season, we'd probably go down and that Cardiff won't be far off it either. 

 

I didn't see the match today, unfortunately, but I popped into the thread to see what everyone was thinking also because I knew there would be a gif of Bacuna's free kick waiting for me. From the position of a Villa fan who didn't see the game, scoring two goals and keeping a clean sheet at home against a team 13th in the Premiership with the amount of injuries we have is a great result.

 

However, I find posts like the above surprising (post simply picked because it was the most recent). Was it really so bad today that you think without those players coming back this team that just won the game is worse than Fulham, Sunderland and Crystal Palace? And that we're worse than Cardiff, despite being above them in the table and the players in question just beating Cardiff 2-0?

 

I just find it amazing that we've reached the top half and people are moaning about how crap we are, whereas last season we were playing attacking football and nearly got relegated...and people were moaning about how crap we were. Either the results tell a story or they don't, right? You can't complain about results when we're losing, then disregard them when we're winning. 

Edited by Panto_Villan
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Figures that I made a point of watching all the other stinkers over the last month but slept through this game, the first one I've missed in over a year. Luckily NBC Sports will show a replay eventually, but watching shoddy videos of goals on youtube will last me until then.

 

God bless Leandro Bacuna

Link to comment
Share on other sites

While Bacuna's free kick was brilliant, I thought it was strange that the keeper never really moved on it. Then my wife noted that with the yellow ball coming over and around the yellow wall, he probably never picked it up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...
Â