I have shown the "new" badge to a few neutrals at work etc and all of them have said pretty much "yeah it's alright".. with a couple of my villa fans friends saying the same who are regulars but wouldn't know what a message board is let alone post on one. Some of them didn't even know about the proposed change but could probably tell you every goal scorer for the last 30 years.
Generally I think, if you post on a message board and get involve with online debates you are probably a more invested fan in these kind of matters but doesn't make you better or hardened. There are thousands that will think this is nice, thousands that don't give a toss but the ones that will get heard are the thousands on these boards who will represent the fan base cause that's the world we live in
I know plenty that didn't get the chance to vote on the last badge cause they dont follow everything on villa socials. Don't look at emails etc. Doesn't make it right how the club have handled it..... I just find it interesting cause I like design and branding.. most of the lads I go with don't give a toss and will go and buy merch whatever.