I think alot of you are quick to right off mcshane, he's very much a RB these days and has more experience than our current RB. He's rough and tough and would pretty much die for his team, i'm not saying that he'd be the making of our team but he'd certainly help and would be a very useful determind defensive player.
I've seen alot of him lately due to villa not playing very often (and having albion mates who go quite alot) and he's been fantastic for them.
He's not jst another Championship player, he's got real quality about him.