I think I've actually changed my mind a little bit over the last year or so of all this badge stuff.
I definitely have a round preference, and I have always said the Name (not the initials), the star and 1874 along with a return to a more traditional Rampant Lion were the building blocks to play with - that and doing away with the yellow on blue of course.
I'm less allied to quite a few of those, But the Rampant Lion and the claret and blue bit are the two I have any strong feelings about.
I'm very much on board with the idea of multiple logos based around the new look if that's what we go with, covers people's shape and detail preferences.