It's been a while, but here we go.
Friedel: 7 - couldn't have stopped either goal and made 1 great save
Cuellar: 5 - defensively ok-ish, but we need more from him going forward, which frankly we're not going to get
Warnock: 4 - didn't get to grips with Valencia, not much of a threat going forward
Dunne: 5 - crucial mistake for the equaliser
Collins: 6 - bit of a nervy start, otherwise ok
Young: 6 - beat his man more often than not, but his final ball was mainly poor
Milner: 8 - always looking for the ball and always dangerous
Petrov: 7 - typical Petrov performance
Downing: 6 - see Young
Heskey: 6 - held the ball up well, but we need more than that
Agbonlahor: 8 MOTM - lead the line well, linked the play, scared their defence shitless and was physically imposing too.
In the end we didn't have enough and they did deserve the win. However, if Mr Dowd had done his job properly it might been a completely different story.