Well it looks to me like the club want a big name rather than someone with a proven track record.
You're delighted because "he's a born winner' (incidentally, he won feck all), leads me to think you are of the same mindset.
With all due respect to his unbeaten season from 3 in Scotland. He would not be near the Villa job if he wasn't a 'big name'
For that reason its a huge risk