Jump to content

VillaTalk blog

  • entries
  • comments
  • views

Contributors to this blog

Player Match Ratings: 2 valuable points thrown away!



One goal is often not enough and so it proved yesterday. Up until Reading’s late equalizer it had looked like we had done just enough to get a win and “just enough” appeared to be all that we had thought that we would need to do.

Our defence is however porous, and we were not capable of closing out yesterday’s game. We have not managed to keep a clean sheet in the league so far this season. That is a feat that we achieved 16 times last season. Our defence, which was so well organised back then with John Terry in it is now crying out for reinforcement, but time is fast running out for us to bring players in.

There was the usual late, late goal at Villa Park yesterday but this time it was our visitors who scored it. We are now four points worse off against the opponents that we have played this season when compared to last season’s results and that is how far we are behind the early pace setters Leeds and Boro. We cannot rely on making up ground lost early in the season on those teams that are in the automatic promotion places now. We need to close the gap between us quickly before it grows into a chasm.

This was a case of after the Lord Mayor’s Show. Our best display of this new season against Brentford was followed by this poor display. We still have our unbeaten record, but this draw feels like a defeat. We seemed to approach this game expecting to win it. We need to go at the throat of teams from start to end to earn a victory and not sit back waiting for it to happen. We regularly need to hit fourth gear rather than coast in second. Any team has a puncher’s chance of getting something from a game when there is only a goal in it.  We may have had the possession, but we didn’t do enough with it.

It is no good raising your game against the better teams in this division and dropping points against the rest. Three points is three points after all and at the final reckoning a win no matter who it came against will remain three points. That 3 points will go towards the final points total that we will need to achieve to finish in the top two. That needs to be our target as we know the play off lottery offers no guarantee of promotion.    

Reading will be happy with a point for their coming battle to remain in this division. They showed little ambition up front until we went a goal ahead but score they did as have every other side we have met in the league to date. We cannot be satisfied with a point. We dropped points last season in games like this one at Villa Park. We have got to start producing our best on a consistent basis against every team that we face this season because if we do not teams will punish us for not doing so. We cannot afford to take any opponent lightly in this league nor should we or we will risk facing another season in it.

My player ratings from a game that brought us a disappointing third successive draw are:

Orjan Nyland – 7 – We may have found a keeper after all. Blocked a close-range effort from a corner by Moore on 44 minutes and then saved a 46th minute Bacuna freekick at his left-hand post. Made a tremendous double save on 82 minutes from Baldock at close range and then from Meite who hit the rebound. Dived to his right and Baldock hit his disputed penalty into the centre of the goal for their late equalizer.  

Axel Tuanzebe – 6 – Another competent performance in what is unlikely to prove his most effective defensive position.     

James Chester- 6 – One rare error from him cost us dearly yesterday. James had looked a clear favourite to reach a ball into the box first in the 3rd Minute of stoppage time but was outpaced by Sims. Their substitute took the opportunity to crumple to the floor with time running out for his side after Chester had won the ball but our captain in going to ground unnecessarily gave the referee a decision to make and he gave the benefit of any doubt to them. James was otherwise his usual steady self on those occasions that our visitors ventured towards our goal. He was unlucky to see a 12th minute header thunder off the crossbar from a nice Elmo cross.      

Mile Jedinak – 6 – Allowed a Sims cross to go past him and only a terrific double save from Nyland prevented Reading from scoring as a result on 82 minutes. Otherwise gave a decent enough performance but this should not be accepted as being his long-term role.        

Alan Hutton – 6 – Gave his usual consistent level of performance.     

Ahmed Elmohamady – 7 – Stooped to head home El Ghazi’s perfect cross on 51 minutes and had a good all-around game.            

Birkir Bjarnason – 7 – Made a good saving tackle on the edge of the box on 9 minutes winning the ball when an opponent was in a threatening position. Gave a very good solid performance throughout.    

Jack Grealish – 6 – Substituted at half time having picked up a dead leg. Hit an effort back across the face of the goal on 41 minutes.  

John McGinn – 7 – MOTM – Looked a class above. Used the ball well and kept very involved. Made an early run into the box but his 1st minute shot was held by Mannone.  

Anwar El Ghazi – 7 – A promising debut. Looks a wide threat, comfortable on the ball and showed a few tricks. Hit a pin point cross for our goal. Made a nice run into the box on 11 minutes and his shot was deflected into the side netting off Mannone. Anwar made way for Albert on 67 minutes.              

Jonathan Kodjia – 5 – What a difference a couple of days can make. From a man of the match 2-goal performance in midweek to this sort of below par display again. Johnny Danger needs some sort of competition for his starting place and was sadly something less than dangerous yesterday. Did not have a great deal of service perhaps but he can do better than this. Flashed a shot over the bar on 62 minutes when others were better placed had he looked to find them. Lost the ball when looking to go it alone on 85 minutes when Hourihane was waiting unmarked inside the box.    


Conor Hourihane – 6 – Came on for Jack at half time and did well. We need to try to find a place for him in the starting line-up. His goals come in handy after all. Hit a shot from the edge of the box on 50 minutes that Mannone collected comfortably and was found by Adomah inside the box in the 69th minute but he hit his shot wide of the far post.  

Albert Adomah – 6 - Replaced El Ghazi on 67 minutes. Made a couple of decent runs and looked lively. Cut inside and hit a 73rd minute shot that was easily gathered by Mannone at the near post and then scuffed a shot 3 minutes later.   

Neil Taylor - Replaced Kodjia on 91 minutes. Not on long enough to gather a rating. 

Up the Villa!

John Lewis


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

  • Posts

    • I'm not. He is one of the best at shithousing but my point was his game was never built on physicality. This has been found out recently as Barca's midfield has been constantly overrun with the physicality of the modern game. They could cope with it 8 - 10 years ago because they had Xavi and Iniesta who never gave away the ball. With a lower quality of player Busquets hasn't been afforded the luxury that he had before and has looked lost as the opposition run around akin to something like a ball in a pinball machine where as he just stands there powerless like an exposed King on a chess board.
    • ...and is therefore a witch?
    • I wouldn't bite their hands off if it means we cut our own hands off and leave ourselves with one recognised striker in the process of doing so either on the basis that Traore will become backup. (We have no Barry now as I have read in one of the other threads that he's got a serious foot injury so he is definately out of the equation) We need to be careful following this mantra incase something were to happen to Olly this season and then pulling in players in from other parts of the team to fill the gaps risks leaving us light in other areas, it's not the doings of a club pushing for a shot at European football. As a whole, he might look useless as a sub to many on here in the few minutes he has been given so far, doesn't mean to write him off as a useless player until we see him given a start somewhere wherever possible if Dean Smith intends on keeping him here unless another situation were to arise between now and deadline day.  
    • Anyone else think we need a quality CB? As for striking options I’d rather we started utilising Barry off the bench instead of Davis. 
    • Yeah, pretty much. 1st - 4th still get Champions League. 5th and 6th get Europa and 7th gets the new one. Of course, if a team from outside these wins the EFL cup or FA cup then they'd get the spot instead, like usual.
    • I was thinking that we could look at bringing someone in that would offer us options on the bench and would either join on loan, with a view to making the deal permanent or be a young player from an EFL team, that are mid-table (so willing sellers). The following list of EFL players was given by Gregor Robertson was in today's Times, that might give us some ideas, for this window or the next: "Hot on the heels of Eberechi Eze, Ollie Watkins, Joe Rodon, Jarrod Bowen et al — all of whom have made the step from EFL to Premier League with relative ease — is a bulging stable of young talent from the British Isles and there is a greater willingness than ever among Premier League clubs, it seems, to recognise their potential. The headline acts this season, perhaps, have been Brentford’s goal-machine Ivan Toney and the mercurial Michael Olise of Reading; and you are well aware, I’m sure, of the skillsets of the likes of Norwich City’s Todd Cantwell and Bournemouth’s David Brooks. But there are plenty more future stars out there — and I was tasked with picking ten of the best. Omar Richards, Reading - From the Championship to the Bundesliga? Richards is entering the final five months of his Reading contract and has been widely linked with a surprise transfer to Bayern Munich, with whom he is now free to negotiate a pre-contract agreement. The 22-year-old, who joined Reading after his release by Fulham aged 16, was converted from left winger to left-back by the coaching staff but has lost none of his attacking intent. Jaap Stam, the former Reading manager, handed Richards his debut in 2017, but since becoming a fixture of the Reading defence over the past 18 months his development has been remarkable. No player in the second tier has made more tackles and it is a rare sight to see a winger beat the south Londoner, who made his England under-21 bow in October 2019. Nathan Collins, Stoke City - Collins, who hails from Leixlip, near Dublin, joined Stoke at 14, has captained Republic of Ireland through the youth ranks, and was handed the armband by Nathan Jones, the former Stoke manager, against Leeds United last season aged just 18. Collins is a commanding presence: 6ft 4in, athletic, but composed enough in possession to have played both at centre half and right back in 19 Championship appearances this season. Several Premier League clubs are reported to be weighing up bids for Collins, who hails from a footballing family. His father, Dave, played for Liverpool and Oxford United; his uncle, Eamon, for Southampton and Colchester United. His brother, Josh, plays in the League of Ireland, as did his late grandfather, Mick. Adam Armstrong, Blackburn - Armstrong is the Championship’s joint-leading goalscorer on 16, alongside Brentford’s Toney, both of whom spent time with Newcastle United in their formative years. Armstrong, who has already equalled last season’s haul, made one Premier League start for Newcastle against Manchester United at Old Trafford in 2014, before loans to Coventry City, Barnsley, Bolton Wanderers and Rovers, which was made permanent in August 2018. The diminutive striker is a bustling, bundle of energy, with intelligent movement and what appears, at times, to be a policy of shoot-on-sight: the 23-year-old has taken on a whopping 122 shots this season, 42 per cent of which have hit the target. Harry Kane is the only player in England’s top two divisions to have uncorked more efforts (124). Ovie Ejaria, Reading - Ejaria is one of the most technically gifted players in the Championship and — closely followed by the Queens Park Rangers winger Bright Osayi Samuel — statistically the second tier’s best dribbler. The rangy, nimble-footed attacking midfielder, who spent nine years in Arsenal’s academy before joining Liverpool in 2014, was loaned to Sunderland, Rangers and Reading, before making the move to the Madejski permanent in the summer. He has flourished with the Royals, often dazzling with moments of virtuoso skill and, crucially, is beginning to improve his creative output — Ejaria has had a hand in six goals this season. Callum Styles, Barnsley - Styles was released by Burnley in early 2016, before joining Bury and making his debut for the Shakers on the final day of the 2015-16 season, aged 16. He joined Barnsley in August 2018 and this season Styles, who is comfortable with both feet, has impressed from the left of midfield in Barnsley’s high-pressing 3-4-3 formation, with his marriage of craft and industry. Only Reading’s Richards has made more tackles, and Styles has scored four goals in all competitions, including a magnificent left-footed strike from outside the penalty area against Nottingham Forest in November, and a low, right-footed drive in Barnsley’s 1-0 win against Norwich City in the FA Cup on Saturday. Brentford, against whom Styles scored in the 2-1 win that secured the Tykes’ Championship status on a thrilling final day of last season, are among the 20-year-old’s suitors. Rico Henry, Brentford - Ok, so Henry’s talents may not be a revelation for most EFL followers. But after missing more than a year of football with a nasty knee injury, in the past two seasons the 23-year-old left back has become a key component in one of the best sides in the Championship. There isn’t much between Richards and Henry, who also couples the pace and energy and attacking forays with defensive rigour — no player has blocked more crosses in the second tier. Henry has clocked up 170 appearances since Dean Smith handed him his debut for Walsall as a 17-year-old, and it was Smith who took Henry to the Bees in 2016, too. Do not be surprised if the Aston Villa manager is among Henry’s suitors again if Brentford fail to win promotion this season. Jason Knight, Derby County - Knight is perhaps the pick of a hugely talented bunch of Rams academy players — including forward Louie Sibley, 19; the midfielder, Max Bird, 20; and the left back, Lee Buchanan, 19 — who have become first-team regulars in the past two seasons. Knight, who can play anywhere across midfield or wide in a front three, is an outstanding ball carrier. The 19-year-old scored six goals last term and has two in 24 Championship starts this season. In the absence of goalkeeper and captain David Marshall, Wayne Rooney, the Derby manager, handed Knight the armband for the past three games, and has made no secret of his admiration for the Dubliner, who has three caps for the Republic of Ireland. “He’s very vocal, which is very rare for a young player these days. He gives everything in training — tackling, running, very similar to the way I was at his age,” Rooney said. “He’s the one — not just for the younger players in the dressing room, but the older lads — who others can look at. He gives you energy, desire, runs non stop.” Harry Pickering, Crewe Alexandra - Another left back! (Can you guess which position I played?) Anyway, Pickering, who has been a permanent fixture in Crewe’s defence for the past four seasons, deserves his place on this list. The academy graduate turned 22 last month and has already clocked up almost 150 appearances. Pickering has a wand of a left foot; his passing and crossing from both open play and set-plays are particular strengths. Crewe rejected a bid from Blackburn Rovers earlier this month. For now a Championship move appears likeliest for Pickering, who has chipped in with three goals and two assists in League One this season, but his ceiling may well be higher. Brennan Johnson, Lincoln City (on loan from Nottingham Forest) - Johnson has been a revelation for Lincoln this season and has drawn covetous glances from Premier League clubs in the process. The 19-year-old, who is the son of former Ipswich Town and Forest striker David Johnson, has a little bit of everything: skill, speed, swagger, and is a creator and scorer of goals. Johnson, who joined the Forest academy aged eight, has seven goals and seven assists in all competitions for Michael Appleton’s League One high-fliers this season and is hugely versatile, comfortable playing anywhere across the forward line. Johnson also made his debut for Wales in a friendly against USA in November. Joel Randall, Exeter City - If a player in League Two is making waves, chances are he plays for Exeter. Since the emergence of Matt Grimes (Swansea City), Ethan Ampadu (Sheffield United, on loan from Chelsea) and Ollie Watkins (Aston Villa) from the Grecians’ academy, Premier League clubs have poached a number of burgeoning talents before Exeter supporters got much of a chance to see them in first-team action. Randall’s path has been a little different. The fleet-footed winger has made an eye-catching breakthrough this season after five loan spells in non-League since 2018. The 21-year-old possesses wonderful close control, is comfortable with both feet and at home on either wing, and has scored eight goals and supplied five assists in all competitions this season. Charlton made an enquiry this month but were priced out, according to manager Lee Bowyer. Swansea City and Celtic have also been credited with interest. Randall is another from good stock: his father, Adrian, enjoyed a 14-year playing career with Bournemouth, Aldershot, Burnley, York City, Bury, and Forest Green Rovers." He later mentions two centre halves, Harry Souttar (Stoke) and Joe Worrall (Forest), along with Reading's Olise (who he did a piece on a couple of weeks ago and said would otherwise have been first on his list). 
    • I'm three tracks deep and just wanna say Treetops is an absolute banger.
    • People saying he should have passed it to Watkins are crazy, Watkins was further away from the goal than Jack was 
    • Nope. None of those will have been expecting Europe at the start of this season.  None of them will want to leave if we don't get it. Grealish may get more attention from other clubs if we're not in Europe, but he signed a 5 year deal presumably with an expectation of progressive sustained development.  A top half finish this season, some astute signings to top up depth and quality, and none of them will need or want to go anywhere else.   Edit: Luiz the exception to the above as if City trigger the buy back and we dont try and buy them out of it, he'll be going regardless of Europe or not i suspect.

  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of use Terms of Use, Cookies We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.