To be fair to that argument, if we had Toney, would we swap him for Watkins, the answer from most would be ‘No’. The fact is there is not much choice between them they just have different strengths.
Ollie deserves the spot after the season he’s had whereas Toney has been out because of his own fault.
Unfortunately life doesn’t work that way and now it’s down to one man that has the tactical ability equivalent of Gerrard.